How do they compare with the Tube Screamer and Klon?
Actually, scratch the Klon, I don't expect you to have owned or played that
Are you liking these pedals?
Cool. Can you dial down the treble in the Soul Food and still get good results?
I'm currently looking for a warm clean boost, and the Soul Food was one of my prime candidates, so the mention of it as "harsh" scares me a little.
Just need a Glove to complete the trio.
I have never played a klon, but my klones I have are part for part, right down to the Russian germanium diodes that are so hard to find.
The Soul Food is a different sound but in the ballpark. I say judge it on its own merits rather than compare it to the Klon or other Klon based designs. Not a bad sounding pedal, but don't expect it to be an exact match for the original Centaur. More like a different flavour of klone, much like there are many different variations on the Tubescreamer that get you that sound, but with their own distinct character.
It feels a bit harsh at high gain levels but that's not where I have it.
I'm currently looking for a warm clean boost, and the Soul Food was one of my prime candidates, so the mention of it as "harsh" scares me a little.
I find it harsh only with gain cranked.
I find it harsh only with gain cranked. Love it for 80% of the gain sweep so if you want it as a boost it's great. And it has an individual treble control so you can tame it.
It's funny, I use my klones to brighten things up a bit. I have a relatively dark rhythm tone so to get my leads to cut through, especially with another guitarist, I turn the treble knob up and use it as a boost.
A friend of mine got an ERD as well and we compared it extensively to the Maxon OD9 I had at the time. We both liked the ERD better, lol, but they were pretty close.
Admitedly, though, my OD9 was an oddball. It did not come with the JRC chip they say it's supposed to come with. I did buy it used, so I can't be sure if it came that way stock, but it didn't look like anyone had been inside that pedal before me.
But anyways, my point is yes, the ERD rules.