I have a DS1 , I think it's good at that fuzzy, thick but fizzy crunch that sort of blends into the mix... A DS2 is that sound, with an optional mid boost? Would probably work well.
He was using a Mitchell amp based on a Mesa on the blue album and I think a Mesa Heartbreaker on 'Pinkerton' so something with a Boogie flavor should get you there.
Also responsible for that sound is the Mesa Boogie, which was still in top condition at this time. The Mesa was run through the tall Marshall, often at unusually low volume, to get some of the sounds on the album. As far as I know, there are NO effects pedals on the guitar sounds on the Blue Album. Rivers would not start really fooling around with recording with effects and pedals till later...
Maladroit has their best guitar sound.
Rockstock pedals Dark horse fuzz
Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk
One diehard blue album / pinkerton fan to another: USA Big Muff with the gain way low, or Taiwan DS-1 with the gain like half way. That'll get you close while you save up for a Mark V or an Orange Rockerverb.
We do a couple Weezer tunes and both of us get decent tones in different ways. The other guitar player uses a combination of swollen pickle and rat into a clean amp and I use my mesa road king on the tweed setting and hit the front end with the distortion side of a MXR/CAE 402. The 402 is set up in a way that would sound absolutely awful on it's own, but it pairs with the tweed setting of channel one in a remarkable way.
Those are cool setups man. Only thing is, I don't like RATs haha. But yeah if it works for the tone then it works for the tone. :headbang: