The Norton or "Air Norton" would be the best choice if you go DiMarzio. The 36th Ann. PAF may be a little too vintage, if you do metal stuff.
Many of us here have, including myself, have dabbled in "hybrid" pickups, where we combine a coil from a hot pickup like a Custom or JB, with a coil from a PAF type like a '59. The Norton is essentially DiMarzio's production model of this idea.
The Duncan Custom is the "PAF on steroids" pickup which many state is a great pickup if you like to shred sometimes and play more classic stuff too.
Personally, I'm in love with my Custom/59 hybrid. It seems like it can do it all!