Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Electric)

Jeff_H

Dean Hardtail Fanologist
.........slap yourself upside the head.

Have you ever gone to change pickups and the pickups you're taking out of the guitar aren't the ones you expected to be in there? It just happened to me.

For the past 6 months or so I thought I had a set of Seth Lovers in my Spalted Maple Hardtail, but I actually had an Antiquity bridge and a Seth Lover neck. I have no idea how that happened. The baseplates look completely different. I obviously confused the two somehow.

Well, I took them out because I had a new set of pickups I wanted to try. They are from James at Rewind Electric http://www.re-wind.net/index.html . I ran into James and his pickups over at My Les Paul Forum. He's a Vendor member there and is active on the board in many of the sub forums, not just the pickup section. He's very knowledgeable about pickups as well as Les Paul's.

Anyhow, I had seen his posts and noticed how helpful he was, even when people were asking questions about other makers pickups. He would give advice, mention things to look for or questions to ask before ordering, all without ever suggesting the person check out his pickups or having a single bad word to say about another brand of pickups. Very much like the attitude we have here about talking about pickups other than SD. We can talk about other pickup brands and we don't rip on those brands because they aren't here to defend themselves. I don't see that attitude very often at other forums I've visited.

I had posted over there as well looking for double cream SD pickups or maybe something else interesting in DC, so James reached out to me and said he had a set in DC that a guy had changed his mind on the color and wanted Zebra instead.... for a Slash inspired build. He offered me a REALLY good deal on the set he already had built. We talked back and forth via PM and email for a while about the sound I was looking for, playing style, music I played and music I liked. In the end, the pickups he had were exactly what I was looking for, but I couldn't afford them. I told him the only way I could do it was to pay 1/2 now and 1/2 later, after some stuff sold, since I'm not working. I told him that wasn't something that I expected him to be interested in, since that's no way to run a business. In the meantime he had someone else contact him looking for the same set of pickups, so he sold them to that person. No big deal, I understand that.

Well, a day or so later I received an email from James offering to build me the same set of pickups, or anything else I wanted that he built, with any custom tweaks I wanted in the sound, for the same crazy low price that he had offered me the other set for. He also said he would take half down or whatever I could do now and I could pay him the rest when I had it. Very Cool!!! I sent the deposit and he built the new pickups and as soon as I had the balance ready, he sent me the pickups.

They are his Low Output Set; about 7.6k for the bridge and 7.3k for the neck, vintage leads and not wax potted. However, now that they're in they sound more powerful than the Antiquity/Seth set I had in the guitar, but with better clarity and note separation. I had to set them lower than the other set to get the sound balanced, at least for low volume clean tones. I just put them in, so I don't have a full review. It's 4am and I can't put the DSL40c on OD1 and see how they sound. On the clean channel they sound very much like a great PAF pickup, which is what they are designed to be. All of the period accurate components, just like Seymour uses on the Antiquities. James even makes many parts himself, to get the details right.

I'll have a better report on the sound and tone after I have them dialed in and a little mileage on them. However, if you are looking for a great set of PAF pickups, from very clear and lower output to the hotter end of the PAF spectrum (and beyond), check out James site http://www.re-wind.net/index.html . If one of his sets isn't exactly what you want, he'll figure out what needs to be done to get that sound and tweak the build process to achieve it. Super amount of integrity and if you buy a set and it doesn't sound right, he'll work with you to get them sounding right or he'll build you another set.

More to come on the tone report, but James is a great guy and you should at least check his site out.

Jeff
 
Last edited:
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

James is very cool. I've dealt with him a LOT, with various winds including a custom 1-off staple p90 he fabricated most of the parts for from scratch.

He also does fixes on vintage pickups - often free of charge. It is one of the reasons why he has ammassed so much knowledge. He has in fact co-authored a PAF pickup book.

https://www.amazon.com/Gibson-P-F-Humbucking-Pickup/dp/1574243640
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Yes, his book is actually on my wish list at Amazon for future reading Alex. James knows a metric ton of stuff, about all pickups for sure. I've read that his P90's are really special. I'm glad your P90 staple turned out well. Very few people would have fabricated parts for a one off project. He really invests his time in the process to find out what you want and need, not what he can sell you.

The Duncan Custom shop will to, within the framework of their system and with their different time restraints. James however, is a true custom shop that has a few standard products. Whether it's James or another small winder, everyone should experience that level of service and the excellent end result.

I'm glad to hear that you've used him too Alex. Good stuff.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Congrats on the rewind set. James is indeed a very cool dude. A JPpost72 set is slotted for my SG restoration. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the low output set. I've seen a set on Reverb for awhile and have been tempted. Will this set make its way to the Les Paul?

Sent from my LG-H931 using Tapatalk
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

One set I own is an early iteration of his PAF 1 set. The K readings are not too dissimilar to the low output set, and as they are 1 of 2 prototype sets I think they might have used some different components in construction compared with the production sets.
Of course K doesn't in any way determine output or tone.....but these seem to be more along the lines of other low wind sets I own rather than the fuller tone most customers report.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

That. Is. Awesome.

It’s a testimony to how important customer service is, and I know I’m willing to pay a hefty premium to have that kind of experience. Not only that, but I also try to tell those stories so others can experience the same thing and so that business or individual can reap the benefits of a job well done.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Cool story. It sounds like he knows exactly how to do business. Because I think that you would have no problem becoming a repeat customer, and your word of mouth review can't be bad for his business.

Sent from my Alcatel_5044C using Tapatalk
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

James is a great guy. Honestly, I’m not too surprised to hear this. Man, I could slap myself for selling my Crème Brûlée set...
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

The Truth is still out there. Thanks for the great review of a great business man.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Congrats on the rewind set. James is indeed a very cool dude. A JPpost72 set is slotted for my SG restoration. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the low output set. I've seen a set on Reverb for awhile and have been tempted. Will this set make its way to the Les Paul?

Sent from my LG-H931 using Tapatalk

That JPpost72 set looks really interesting. The hotter PAF neck and the T-Top with lower output will make a great mix. I know that the DCR readings are not a true indicator of output, but having used only SD pickups for 17 years I've learned how to judge and compare SD pickups based on that. What James's set is showing me is that "Low Output" does not equal a weak sound. I'll be interested to hear how you like your set when you get them.

These pickups are dynamic and strong and I don't have to set them any closer to the strings to get the balanced tone I'm looking for. I haven't had a chance to spend enough time with them to give a review, but I can tell you that I already love the tone with them set at just my normal starting heights. They have punch and dynamics and depth that I know will get better.

I'm not sure they'll make it to my 57' RI. I have a set of pickups in there that suit that guitar perfectly. They are from a guy I met on Reverb during another transaction. His name is CM Daugherty. He's a small pickup maker from Texas. He built me a set of his 57' PAF repros and they were just perfect in my RI.

I have James set in my USA Dean Hardtail with Spalted Maple top.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

One set I own is an early iteration of his PAF 1 set. The K readings are not too dissimilar to the low output set, and as they are 1 of 2 prototype sets I think they might have used some different components in construction compared with the production sets.
Of course K doesn't in any way determine output or tone.....but these seem to be more along the lines of other low wind sets I own rather than the fuller tone most customers report.

That sounds like a very interesting set. I looked very hard at the PAF-1 set since it had won that Canadian PAF shootout. I was initially concerned about the high DCR readings, especially in the neck, as I don't like the neck to lose clarity. However, I'm now convinced that the neck from that set will still retain the clarity James states it will.

You're lucky to have a prototype set like that from James. He really knows what he's doing.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

That. Is. Awesome.

It’s a testimony to how important customer service is, and I know I’m willing to pay a hefty premium to have that kind of experience. Not only that, but I also try to tell those stories so others can experience the same thing and so that business or individual can reap the benefits of a job well done.

I've always felt a good sense of customer service from SD and in my experience they work very hard to resolve customer issues. With that said, you can get a different level of service from a smaller pickup builder than SD can possibly give to all of its customers. It's not a competition of course, but James is a true custom shop and he prefers to have several conversations with you so he can do all possible to guide you to the set you want.

I always like to share stories about good service, like you do Will. It's neat to be on the receiving end of such service. It's unfortunately not common anymore to receive such good service. I hope you get to check out James pickups at some point, since you're delving into lower output pickups.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Cool story. It sounds like he knows exactly how to do business. Because I think that you would have no problem becoming a repeat customer, and your word of mouth review can't be bad for his business.

Sent from my Alcatel_5044C using Tapatalk

I'll definitely buy more pickups in the future. It's just neat to see old fashioned customer service.

James is a great guy. Honestly, I’m not too surprised to hear this. Man, I could slap myself for selling my Crème Brûlée set...

That set sounds really interesting too. Sorry you sold them but hopefully you can acquire another set sometime.

The Truth is still out there. Thanks for the great review of a great business man.

Absolutely. I do think there are a lot of small businesses out there that really give great customer service. The news just doesn't make it very far, so I like to share it when I experience it.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

That sounds like a very interesting set. I looked very hard at the PAF-1 set since it had won that Canadian PAF shootout. I was initially concerned about the high DCR readings, especially in the neck, as I don't like the neck to lose clarity. However, I'm now convinced that the neck from that set will still retain the clarity James states it will.

You're lucky to have a prototype set like that from James. He really knows what he's doing.

I too got into James from the Canadian PAF shootout. I asked about the PAF 1 and must have got in early....or he took pity on me...or something else. Mine read in the 7.6 and 7.4 range.....and originally he said to put the higher K one in the neck and try them out like that. I have had them in 2 different guitars and they've not quite found their home, but I'm giving them a 3rd shot - this time with the typical K positioning.
When I asked about the low K readings, he said the tone would be the same as the production set, but he'd used some special wire for the prototypes just for something different. He also did some prototyping on the bobbins....so they are an aged doublecream with special mould marks and wear on the tops.

As to the high K readings - I have a set from Sigil....the LTD edition bluesman roots set with the 1957 era vintage wire. They read in at 8.6 and 8.2. But fitted in a couple of guitars now they retain a strong stinging edge to the tone - similar to what you'd expect from a low K wind. They really seem to nail The Supernatural like no other PAF clone I have bought does.
 
Last edited:
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

I've looked at several of the Sigil pickup sets as well. I turned down an offer on his 57' Roots pickups used from someone at MLP forum to go with James set. I was again worried about the high neck dcr readings. I'm happy to hear your review because several of the Sigil sets really appeal to me in their description. He's another of the small wonders that I really want to try out.

My problem is wanting to try too many different pickups and not having enough guitars to accomplish that!
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Ah, but thats the power of enabling. You buy the pickups, then get a nice guitar model/style you've always wanted to try in order to have a host for the pickups.
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

You should consider Tyson Tone and Wizz into the mix as well. They're other small builders with attention to detail. I have to install my TTL-2 set in a Koa 356, but the Wizz pickups are phenomenal. I have the NOS wire versions and I don't think I would ever sell the set. They are less picky about the guitars they sit in while the Sigil Vintage Wire were more picky.

Sent from my LG-H931 using Tapatalk
 
Re: Sometimes You Just Have To......(A Story and New Pickup Install From Rewind Elect

Ah, but thats the power of enabling. You buy the pickups, then get a nice guitar model/style you've always wanted to try in order to have a host for the pickups.

Ah yes, I'm very familiar with that concept. Once I'm working again I'll probably pick up another guitar or two that I've wanted. I want another LP, either a light Standard or Traditional with a nice top, a Gold Top or maybe a 59' RI if I can get a good deal. I'd also like to have a Hardtail Charvel San Dimas.

You should consider Tyson Tone and Wizz into the mix as well. They're other small builders with attention to detail. I have to install my TTL-2 set in a Koa 356, but the Wizz pickups are phenomenal. I have the NOS wire versions and I don't think I would ever sell the set. They are less picky about the guitars they sit in while the Sigil Vintage Wire were more picky.

Sent from my LG-H931 using Tapatalk

Yes, there are several other pickups makers I'd like to try. I have a list somewhere. Tyson Tone, Wizz, Siegil, Electric City, Zhangbucker pure hand wound and others I can't recall right now. Those vintage wire sets are really interesting to me a d I'd like to test drive a set for sure. It's good to know the Wizz aren't guitar picky but the Sigil set is.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top