Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

dr.barlo

New member
Hey guys,

First I am not talking about the 2nd and 4th position quack. I am talking about the quack from a s/c pickup only. For example the quack rendered by the JD. If that is confusing, then lets call it quack' !!! :laugh2:

I have been through some bunch of strat pickups for my 01 sienna burst ash body maple neck lone star strat. It is a great guitar, and I wanna get a very strat strat out of it. Am not looking for the SRV tone, BUT the Clapton's tone on the Layla album (think of "I looked away"). It should be crunchy, defined, wild (if overdriven), crisp clear, not too powerful not needed, yet I need a very defined well pronounced bass, not ruining the chime and all.

On that guitar let me talk about the ones I have tried.

1. fender tx specials: were stock, they had an annoying mid hump, and not clear enough bass. It was more lowermids, than a defined bass. They sounded like overwound strat sc's (more mids less treble, less bass) and that's not what I want.

2. van zandt blues bridge; van zandt vintage + neck and middle: This is a great set and I have this set on my 90 sunburst. It does very good SRV, but for this guitar as I said above I want the more clear, the more strat strat tone. And there is no fun when all my guitars sound exactly the same no? Yet the van zandt blues bridge sounds very close to what I want. That's my default option for now. The neck and middle, well we'll see.

3. lindy fralin vintage hot neck and middle and SD ant custom bridge: That is a great set for overdrive. Yet all of them are a bit on the polite side. What I mean is:

3.a. Fralins in the neck and middle: They got the chime, they got the crisp clear tone, BUT NOT the bass, it is lacking. The definition is great, yet I need more well pronounced, room shaking bass. To get what I want imagine E7 in the fifth position, low E open. I want that low E to cut acros the whole chord and stand out. But meanwhile, I don't wanna get a too bassy pickup, no way. Basically I wanna retain all the qualities of the fralins and add more bass, more well defined and pronounced bass.

3.b. ant custom: great pickup, and I see why many LOVE that. It turns the stock guitar from an ice machine into a smooth, yet still strat tone machine. It almost can cope with HBs with the tone rolled down and all, and has a very singing tone. Yet it still is a strat bridge pickup.

I am not letting mine go, yet that pickup does not have the quack. It sort of has that upfront tone of p90s, no quack, (relatively speaking of course), is somewhat flat (again relatively speaking, is no way close to being flat in absolute terms).

In order to see if I can add bass and highs to scoop the eq a little bit and make it a more strat bridge pickup, I installed one fralin base plate to that pickup. It helped, yet still no cigar. So for those of you who think your bridge tone might use a little bit more highs and bass with the strat ant custom, spending $10 on a fralin bass plate does the trick! ;)



So what do I do? The things that come to my mind (after Lew's input) are ant II's. As I said my default now is a van zandt blues bridge. I lvoe that pickup, but I guess this time given a high probability of success, I'd rather get something new.

Another thing I have thought of is to put a custom shop order for a JD to fit the strat bridge position. 7.80K with the base plate and all... There the problem is that I know the JD on a tele, hence the tele bridge and all. And that might affect the tone, I mean a JD in a strat might not sound as it does in a tele. What do you think?

BTW I'd love to hear from those of you who have tried other scatter wound ones, like voodoos, rolphs, (I don't mind the hum, in fact I like it :smack: so I am not listing kinmans here) wagners, and others I don't know.

Regards,

B
 
Last edited:
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

Doc,
I have a question .... do you think the balance of the pups affects quack?

because, after trying different tele pups, I think the tone of the in between positions is pretty dedpendent on the balance of the pickups. I guess that might seem obvious, but it was emphasized by trying different combos.

I guess my point is that I believe a well balanced set helps the 'quack factor'.
 
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

Maybe something like a Duncan 5/2 PuP may get you close ? A large
part of the chime on the Layla album was from Clapton's amp. He
was useing a Fender champ.
 
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

Curly,

Yeah, the balance of the pickups definitely affect the quack from the inbetween positions. On teles what I love is to have the bridge overpower the neck (bridge quite close to the strings) then the quack is to die for. JD for example does that with a ant hb in the neck (yes, JD close enough DOES overpower the ant neck HB).

On my 01 mary kay white with the fralin blues sp tele lead in the bridge, I used a low DC middle pickup, ~5.90K. And the quack in position 2 and 4 did increase.

But in my initial post I was not talking about the quack from the in between positions. I am talking about the quack from a single pickup. I remember you have the JD tele lead no? Now that pickup has quack! See what I mean?

B
 
Last edited:
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

kmcguitars said:
Maybe something like a Duncan 5/2 PuP may get you close ? A large
part of the chime on the Layla album was from Clapton's amp. He
was useing a Fender champ.

Yeah sure. My amp is not that bright I know that, yet I can get close to that with the setup I have using my non-staggered stock fender s/c (from a 90 american strat). So I know it can be done on my rig.

Why am I not using those 90 stock set; well they are good there but shrill, icepicky. Hence my quest for the hand-scatter wound ones. And the other thing is they don't have the bass I need.

And my guy feeling tells me I should rather stay away from 5/2's since I don't find my lindy fralin vintage hots (or my van zandts) overly bright or anything. In fact all I need is more defined and well pronounced bass from my fralins.

B
 
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

try that surfer bridge as lew suggested. i only dropped it in for a few days but i thought it nailed that layla album tone. especially into a little gibson tube amp or a bf princeton.
i called an impromptu jam session to see how it sounded and told my buddy to bring his princeton. very nice result. this was in a maple neck alder body hardtail strat and the tones were bright but not shrill. tight bottom and clean mids, doesnt push an amp the way the texas hots do. stays a little more defined with a little more spank, that might be what you are describing with quack.
 
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

Thanks Jeremy. Ok I am set to go for the ant II's then!

BTW you might be right, spank or quack??? Dunno. Spank means the following for me: pick and pull (with the middle finger) the same string say A on G. What I hear in the bridge position is spank for me. Where as quack is something to the with the eq fqs to be so well separated that even when picking a chord, each of the eq of individual strings each can be heard somewhat separately. Do I make sense?

Anyway Lew and you is more than enough encouragement for the Ant IIs. Gonna get them pretty soon then.

One question: at that kinda high DC does the custom ant II still have that spanky strat bridge tone like a 7.00-7.30 a5 strat bridge pickup? Or will it have more of a p90 kinda flatter, less spanky tone. I guess I am just asking to get a confirmation before settling on it.

B
 
Re: Strat Single Coil Quest: Quack

I think in order to get quack tones in between positions middle pickup should be lowered significantly compared to neck/bridge...am I wrong?
I always set my pickups way low and I guess I get much better tones with that setting...
 
Back
Top