Hmm... I like my TR-2, but you're right, but it doesn't quite have the chop of an optical tremolo. Any recommendations for a good reasonably priced optical tremolo? I see the EHX Pulsar is on sale for $50 right now at sweetwater
Pulsar - just no.
Let go of the "optical" thing. Square wave is square wave. There are lots of ways to generate that.
For great chop, get a Duncan Shapeshifter. Seriously. Or, just get one because they are awesome. Either way.
Earthquaker Hummingbird is awesome too. There is a reason it is called "repeat percussion"
Honestly, the TR-2 is pretty good. Seriously.
However, if what you really think you want is optical because classic/historic sound, Yes, an EXH Pulsar is optical tones. But...a classier choice with that Surfy would be an Original large box Diamond Tremolo. But The Mooer Trelicopter is also Optical (allegedly)
Or - to go outside the box, for extreme Chop consider the Idiot Box Stutter. On/off is about as chop as chop gets.
I just can't tell where you are coming from. I mean, I'm just being cork-sniffy on needing something other than the TR2 to pair with the Surfy.
- Set up that works? Surfy + TR2 (which is neither bias or optical, but does a great chop)
- Set up that works and is optical? Surfy + Mooer Trelicopter (Is it really optical or does it just sound that way - yet it has a bias knob - point being ignore the mechanism)
- Setup that is more excellent? Surfy + Hummingbird (also optical, by the way)
- Setup with Optical awesome? Surfy + Diamond
If what you want is Fender replication, sell it all and get a Fender Tre-Verb.