Re: Swirl Marks
I can totally appreciate the desire to want your guitar to look perfect.
However, look at all the major guitar gods out there and what their main axes look like. For example, check out Steve Vai's web site and look at his main guitar EVO. Talk about a beat up instrument, but he loves the tone out of it.
For a next guitar, you could look at a natural wood look with a rubbed oil finish. You won't get swirl marks, and if it got any scratches or nicks, you can just lightly sand it away, and rub more oil on it and it looks like new.
Best of luck.