Re: Tele pickups for Squire
The material the body is made from is one of the factors that will decide which pickups will do best for you. I won't speak for everyone but my experience has been that in a nice ash Tele, Alnico 2 pickups work best. They produce the tone that suits me best. Alnico 5 pickups tend to be a bit too bright. It also depends on the windings and wire used in the pickups. I have heard Alnico 2 pickups in ash and they have been too bright in some cases. I had a poplar bodied Tele with a B-bender. I used a JD model and it as well as the stock pickups were the best. The JD has Alnico 2 and the stock had alnico 5. I installed a Fender Nocaster pickup in that Tele and it sounded horrible. Nocaster pickups use Alnico 3 magnets which have a different lower mid and bass responce altogether. The Squiers are made from Agathis right? I believe they have tonal features similar to mahogany; which can be warm and deep sounding.
The tone you're after is that of a '55 Esquier right? Well, I might be wrong, but I believe that in '55, Fender started using the smaller diemeter poles as well as raising the D & G poles a bit. This would result in a slightly thinner twangier tone. I would recommend you try 3 models.
1. STL-1 Vintage 54
2. STL-1b Broadcaster
3. APTL-3JD Jerry Donahue model