So I'm going to be the weirdo on this thread.. I could care less what a pickup looks like, to me form follows function. So all I care about is good sound and usability.
Now I have to admit that the form follows function thing grows on me. I love strats to death and have almost no use for a Jaguar. That's just me, not saying Jags aren't good...
So I'm going to gravitate towards a strat looking pickup and away from something that looks jaguarish because I'm after a strat sound. Strangely enough, I loved the demo for the new fender strat Cunefe But I didn't like the look because it is in a metal case that reminds me of a Jaguar. But that's likely to change relatively quickly cuz I'm definitely getting a set
Same thing with Minnie's, Firebirds all the cool pickups on display here (especially the Rail Hammer, the first in Beau Brummels photos ).
And now thst I think about it, the Reverend Rail Hammer maybe my case in point. I wasn't originally attracted to it... It's got way oversized slugs and the other half are rails so I imagine it confuses a lot of people. From my perspective, the look had no associated meaning.
But after getting one of my own and installing them for others, it's clear that it's a ridiculously good pickup and a lot has to do with the look. Those big pole pieces soften the highs and the rails tighten the bass. I think they'd probably sell a whole bunch more of them if they throw a cover over top and just let people listen to them.
So, for me it's a great example of falling in love with something because of what it does, not how it looks.
I don't want to come off as negative and definitely want you guys to enjoy the thread and the visual artistry that I lack ...but I did want to provide at least one pass as the devil's advocate for what it's worth.