These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

Jeff_H

Dean Hardtail Fanologist
Elixir's. The Taylor's come standard with the Elixir Lights (12's). On the 02 model I have the strings were more worn that I realized when I A/B'd them with the 30th Ann. I went out and got a couple of different gauges of Elixir's, and also a pack of Martin Strings. GJ had told me several times that I couldn't really judge a Martin unless it had a new set of strings, and most of the Martins in the stores have had super grody strings. Well, I don't own a Martin, but I thought a new set of the strings that they recommend, strung on one of my guitars would be a nice comparison, since they are so different from the Elixir's.

Strung up the 02' with the Martins (12's) and A/B'd them with the Elixir's (12's also) on my 30th Ann. The Martin strings have much more of a metallic sound to them. They are a darker bronze, and have an overall rougher feel on the wound strings as compared to the Elixir's. They have quite a bit of string squeak as well, which I haven't had on my Taylor thus far. While the tone of the Martins was still crisp, they were also somewhat dark. The articulation did not seem as clear. They made my Taylor sound slightly deeper, but not as complex. They are also fairly rough, and I feel like I have to fight them quite a bit.

I played the set of Martin strings for a little over an hour sitting on the back porch. Streched them out good and gave them the once over. Long story short, I went back inside and took them off, and put on a set of Elixir's. I went with a slightly lighter guage, the Custom Lights, which have an 11 on top instead of 12, and all the other stings are one number less than the Standard Lights. It was a night and day difference on the same guitar. The tone was crisper, more articulate, but still with great warmth. The other most noticable difference is the string squeak, and the ease with which they play.

Elixir makes 2 types of Acoustic Strings, one is called "Nanoweb" and the other is called "Polyweb". The Nanoweb, which is what was originally on my 02, have a super thin coating of whatever Elixir coats them in, and are a brighter sounding string with more pop. The Polyweb has a slightly thicker coating than the Nano, and the strings are warmer and smoother, and offer a slightly darker tone with even more reduced string squeak. The Polywebs are my choice from now on for my Taylor.

At $13 bucks a set, they are quite spendy, but for the tone they impart to my Taylor, and if they really last as long as purported, they will be a great investment. The Martins set me back $8, and I didn't care for them one bit.

I just thought some of you might find this interesing and useful. I knew that different brands of strings would sound slightly different, but I'm realizing that on acoustics the difference is much more noticable than compared to electric. You have to invest in a good set of strings for a good acoustic tone.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

I couldnt agree with you more, I use elixir polywebs for all of my guitars. I even use them on all of my electrics because of how they feel (SMOOOOOTH)
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

i use nanowebs for my acoustic. i love them. me being the morron i am decided to try some martin strings, and they sucked. i cant wait to take em off.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

I've used Martins forever, and always thought they were great, until I used the Polywebs, now I'm stuck on 'em.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

I have to respectfully disagree. I've used Elixirs several times and don't like the tone and feel of them. I prefer uncoated phosphor/bronze strings and normally use either D'Addario EJ16's or Martin SP4100's. Yesterday I bought a set of Martin 80/20's that I'm going to try out some time.

Each to their own though. Strings and bridge pins are the most inexpensive tone changers there are.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

sgstrat said:
I have to respectfully disagree. I've used Elixirs several times and don't like the tone and feel of them. I prefer uncoated phosphor/bronze strings and normally use either D'Addario EJ16's or Martin SP4100's. Yesterday I bought a set of Martin 80/20's that I'm going to try out some time.

Each to their own though. Strings and bridge pins are the most inexpensive tone changers there are.

dont forget saddles and nuts too, I can buy a shaped unslotted acoustic nut for about 9 bucks.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

i love elixirs on my strat. it gives a thicker sound. elixir sent me a set of developmental strings which use a different wrap on the plain steel electric strings and i put them on my les paul. i didnt like them after a while. the wrap on the high strings seemed to do nothing, and i definteely prefer the uncoated sound of my d'addario strings on my les paul alot more. d'addario 11's are they way to go there.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

i use d'addario 9s on my electrics, 10s on my acoustics...i've tried elixirs before, and the coating comes off after a week or so...i also think they arent worth 3x the price. Much of that money is for advertising and packaging- they could cut the price in half with a simpler package. No way the coating alone costs 2x the base string price.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

The elixers have a good sound on the Taylor guitars. IMHO the Taylors have a brighter sound, agood sound, but brighter. The coated strings are often help to balance the sound. I have tried and like the D'addario EXP's light gauge. I find they have a good comprimise and the coating hasn't come off on me. They cost less than the Elixers.

That's just me though.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

Rstlessone said:
The elixers have a good sound on the Taylor guitars. IMHO the Taylors have a brighter sound, agood sound, but brighter. The coated strings are often help to balance the sound. I have tried and like the D'addario EXP's light gauge. I find they have a good comprimise and the coating hasn't come off on me. They cost less than the Elixers.

That's just me though.


No, not just you. I like the D'Addario coated strings also. The coating seems thinner to me than the Elixir, which I like.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

Yeah....the coating does eventually wear off. It just seems to last longer from what I've been able to tell so far. I would guess that the Nanoweb coating would be similar to the coating on the D'Addario's, since you guys say it's so thin. The thing I really like is the smoothness and the non-squeak factor. It feels closer to an electric, which I prefer, but with that distinct acoustic tone.

They are definatley more expensive. Is it worth it. that's a personal choice, and it is for me. Taylor picked these strings to best compliment their tone. I read an article that says Bob Taylor only changes the strings on the accoustic that he keeps in his office about every 6 months. If mine last that long I'll be extatic.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

Elixir 12's and 11's are the big sexy for acoustic strings! Love 'em!
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

The thing about D'Addario's coated strings is that they coat the bronze winding and THEN wind the string. Is Elixir doing the same thing with their Nanowebs, or is it like the Poly's where the string is wound and then coated?
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

Benjy_26 said:
The thing about D'Addario's coated strings is that they coat the bronze winding and THEN wind the string. Is Elixir doing the same thing with their Nanowebs, or is it like the Poly's where the string is wound and then coated?

Actually the Nanoweb stuff is coated just the same way as the Poly stuff is but the physical thickness of the coating on the Nanoweb strings is thinner, resulting in not so much of a "slippery" feel to them. I prefer Nanoweb.

I didn't really like the D'addario EXPs because they had less sustain, less tone and felt much too stiff.
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

I know what you guys mean about not being happy with Martin strings. For some reason, I always find something I don't like about them, too.
My only requirements are Phosphor Bronze 12's with nickel/silver B & E strings.
I hate paying so much for Elixirs, so I just buy the D'Addario 3 pack of 12's.
I may start experimenting with other brands, but I'm not too picky......just as long as theyr'e not Bronze with bronze B & E.....I hate those!
 
Re: These Acoustic Strings Really Are The Bomb

I have an '88 Taylor 810. I've tried Martins on it a few times and never really dug them. I like the D'Addarios too...phos. bronze mediums. I got a set of Elixirs once for free from a tech. I liked them, and thought they sounded better as the coating wore off. Wierd to see shreds of the coating on the strings. But like joneser, I just buy those 3-packs of D'Addarios. I haven't found anything that I thought sounded better on that guitar. They last a long time as long as I wipe them down after I play.
 
Back
Top