Re: Thinking about building a Tele from Warmoth. Thoughts? Experiences?
I've never paid much attention to any of the guitar building stuff, but I want a tele and don't particularly want to dish out a ton on it. I'm looking at Warmoth because I've got a set of Duncan Antiquity P90's and think a Tele body/neck would make a nice home.
I've made two so far - one jazzmaster w/ strat bridge and one telecaster style with a bigsby bridge.
First, they do make good stuff - the bodies I've gotten from them are awesome. BUT, always check
usa custom guitars web specials first. They have the same quality bodies as warmoth but often times as much as $50 cheaper ($99 vs. $155 for warmoth's cheapest in stock-er).
I've never purchased a neck from warmoth - that's because the first one came from USACG (another web special on the cheap) and the second one I believe was a musikraft (had it sitting around for some time so idk if it really is)
You can also get cheap necks on the bay. I've found a $139 neck that has the fat baseball bat contour and a 9.5" radius (which is my favorite w/ the action I use), which is considerably less than the $157 warmoth charges.
They say that you need a double-adjustable truss rod, because what if your neck is so far backbowed that you actually have to dial in relief going the other way, even with string tension? Also something about the 14th fret popping up after 20 years. I'm sure the double adjustable truss rod is wonderful on the small portion of necks manufactured so poorly that you need to dial in more neck bow (rather than less) but I highly doubt the QC people at Warmoth would let such a neck make it all the way into a customer's hands.
Anyway, once you decide to put a guitar together, be careful. You can spend just as much money building a guitar yourself than just buying one. I got a finished esquire body on here for $80 and it's still going to be nearly $400 for a one pickup solid body guitar before its all said and done. You need to remember all of the little ancillary bits that end up driving the cost so high.
What kind of tuners do you want? You're going to need some pickguard screws too. What about electronics? Are you going to need a special (4-way) switch? Strap buttons, string guides, shielding, pickguards, paint, and a nut (more than a few necks come without one pre-installed) can easily add up to over $100 before you know it.
Also, remember that while you can have someone like warmoth finish the guitar for you, it's like $30-40 in paint from the guitar reranch vs. like $130 for warmoth to paint it for you. If you really don't care about having nitrocelluose vs. polyurethane, you can put on a good poly finish with less than $20 in paint and materials from lowes or home depot. If you want it to be immaculate, you're probably gonna need to get a pack of 1000-2000 grit sandpaper from your local autoparts store and some rubbing and buffing compound.
Another benefit of poly finishes is that you don't have to wait like a week before it's ready to wet sand. You can go from bare wood to wet sanded and buffed in a weekend. Some people swear by nitro and to be honest that's all I've ever used but plenty of people use poly and they don't seem to have any problems or the like.
For the neck, I wouldn't recommend buying a finished neck. Tru oil is cheap and a single bottle can do like 3-4 necks if you apply it thin enough.
Another option for a base/finish is shellac - you can buy different tints from luthier's mercantile international, and you dissolve the flakes in a bowl of denatured alcohol (be careful though, that stuff will eat the paint off of most things if you spill it) and then you take some cotton balls and place them in a square of fabric made from an old t-shirt, then you take a rubber band and tie that around the cotton balls so you have this kind of pillow that you use to apply the shellac. Then before you dip the pillow in the solution you take a single drop of olive oil or some other oil to lubricate everything. Then you make swirling motions as though you're polishing the instrument - what happens is the dissolved denatured alcohol carries fine particulate shellac onto the face of the guitar and then evaporates, leaving the shellac.
A bonus of the shellac finish is that it's the same thing they use on jelly bellies. It's also the finishing technique they use on high-end violins and the like because it lets the wood 'resonate the best' although I don't know how much of a difference it makes.
I've finished one neck in shellac and tru-oil (jazzmaster) and another came with a sprayed on shellac finish. The french polish finish is going to be a lot smoother than the spray on (kind of like satin vs. gloss) but the tru oil finish wipes the floor with both of them. I mean, it's like if teflon had just enough drag that you could tell how far you had moved up or down the neck just on feel.
To conclude, if you choose to build a guitar, you're looking at either a lot of time, or a lot of cost, or a kind of low quality build. It's a ton of fun, and I wouldn't sell either of the guitars I put together for any amount of money, but just be well aware of what you're getting into before you do.
TBH if you just want to hear the pickups you're probably better off getting a cheapo depot guitar and just chiseling out the wood to route for the p-90s. If you want to spend a few weeks looking at parts and don't mind doing some drilling and/or finish work you can probably put something together for like $375 or so. (~$180 for the neck + hardware, ~$120 for a cheap but decent solidbody + paint, ~$75 for the hardware)