Re: Weird Fender Locking Saddles
It is quite an amazing invention when you think about it.
Not really. It's just an extension of Fender's original trem design. Several people back in the 70's (including me) were modding Fender whammies by eliminating the middle 4 hold down screws, experimenting with locking strings onto tuners, etc. Also, the initial design was very crude. Setting individual intonation was a colossal PITA with the strings locked under tension. You basically loosened the string, moved the saddle, and then tuned it back up until you had it "in tune" or you just said "close enough".
The first time a rep showed me a Floyd Rose in the box (1980?), I asked if this was simply a prototype. I was appalled to find out this was the production model. It was so crude. No individual height adjustment, and installing the locking nut? There was no instruction sheet in the box. I had to figure out by myself what dimensions to rout for proper placement. AND - to this very day, there is still no way to set individual string height at the nut, and one string is nearly ALWAYS too high or too low. You have to juggle it around. Now most factories just rout the shelf purposely too low, and furnish metal shimstock to set the action.
Anyone know who Floyd Rose was? He was a jeweler who played a Strat. And the initial Floyd looked like a guitar part made by a jeweler, doesn't it? No real engineering thought behind the design, and they haven't made many changes in the decades since beyond adding fine tuners.
I was around then when the damn thing came out. Eddie Van Halen gets most of the glory, AND the blame for the popularity of the thing. In an interview he was asked how he liked it. His answer? "I like it, and I don't". So he wasn't thrilled anymore than 95% of the guitar techs who work on these POS to make clients happy. I have to work on 'em, I've written about 'em several times, and I hate 'em.
A good Wilkinson with locking tuners makes more sense, and a Kahler is the ultimate unit for adjustability and performance. Period.