What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

It's also a much lower impedence than a dummy coil.

There is a bit of loss in terms of the treble. I personally think that a bit of hum is fine, and would use this just to decrease the hum instead of expecting it to be noiseless.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I have tried way too many noiseless pickups from different manufacturers (Including Fender, Seymour Duncan, Dimarzio, and Lollar pups) and also have used the Suhr BPSSC.

It breaks down to two noiseless pickups from different manufacturers ...

Zexcoils - Fat Series (First picture)

Kinman - Big Nine O (Second picture)
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1697.jpg
    IMG_1697.jpg
    67.2 KB · Views: 0
  • IMG_1692.jpg
    IMG_1692.jpg
    59.5 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

Even though the thread was just bumped after 2 years -

If it has to be a self contained pickup - Rails for me. Barden or Vintage Rails.

Not self contained - A single and Ilitch's routed in noise canceling coil (The one Suhr used to install in their guitars) or the Suhr SSC II if the guitar is a Suhr. To me, that is IT! Both very effective and an almost imperceptible difference in tone. I do have Suhr with the Ilitch and an on/off switch for the SSC.

Ilitch also has the system mounted on a pick guard, reported to be as effective as the routed in coil. I might get one in a couple of months.

I've had 2 set of Wildes - L-280 and the L-200.
I did not like the L-280, not Strat like to me. L-200 was the best of the stacks I've tried, but seemed to lack some low end.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

LReese said:
I've had 2 set of Wildes - L-280 and the L-200.
I did not like the L-280, not Strat like to me. L-200 was the best of the stacks I've tried, but seemed to lack some low end.
Click to expand...

Thats what a lot of people say about the L-280s who are use to that scoop and sound of traditional singles. Thats why the L-200s were introduced. The 280's are more versatile but the 200s give you that strat tone easier.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

Killer single coil tone in a noiseless? Try the newer DiMarzio Area series (58/61/67) or most of the Kinman offerings...good stuff!
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

For rock, i'd say some fast track II/I - chopper, or coolrails/hotrails in parallel.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

LReese said:
I've had 2 set of Wildes - L-280 and the L-200.
I did not like the L-280, not Strat like to me. L-200 was the best of the stacks I've tried, but seemed to lack some low end.
Click to expand...

I have one guitar loaded with L280s. Its primary mission is to provide a noiseless option if I find myself in an enviroment that makes using regular single coils a big problem. Otherwise, I have non noiseless single coils in my main player strats. The tone is worth the hum.

I saw Eric Johnson play several years ago and he was getting so much noise that it was interfering with the music in a big time way. Finally, he just stopped playing and started talking to a roadie, changing cables around and stuff, but then he saw a nearby air fan that was on. After he kicked it off the stage the noise was reduced to normal levels. LOL
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I've got HSS Kinmans in one guitar. Two 62s and an Extra Vintage HB. Really great pickups. They are technologically clever, and they do what they say.

I've got a Joe Barden tele neck pickup and a JB trembucker in my tele.

Now I'm looking for a noiseless middle Strat pickup to Nashville-ize the tele.

Looking at Dimarzio area 58 and Seymour STK-S4 as possibilities.

It would be great if there was a shootout of these and the Kinmans on the Web somewhere.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

If I had posted in this thread when it first began, I would have been entirely unsurprised to find that my opinion then would have been the same as it is today.

Not one of the noise-cancelling Stratocaster (or Telecaster or Jazz Bass or P-90) replacement pickups accurately captures the tones of a true single coil.

I'll take Antiquity II Surfers + a good noise gate, please.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I'm still on the (insert your favorite Single Coil) and Ilitch product kick as the best no-noise solution. If you want a whole guitar, Suhr's current solution works just as well. Fishman's Fluence product is also great if you don't mind batteries.

That being said, I'm getting less bothered these days from the 60z noise from Strats. Then again, I'm not a gainiac. I also dislike noise gates ( sorry, they give the sound a weird feel IMO but of course YMMV)
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I agree Antiquity II pickups and some extra caution during build/install and "noise" is of no significance. In general I have seen that installation and set up play a serious role/factor in the reduction of "noise" from single coil pickups.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I love the tone and feel of Duckbuckers or vintage rails, they are the only noiseless vintage single coil style pickups I have installed. Not single coilish, but have a sweet treble, silky mids with a nice, slightly compressed pick response.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I love my Wilde pickups....not just because they are very quiet, but it is the sound and usefulness that really makes me love them.
I can change the sound with the toneknobs, it is not just rolling off the topend anymore, they react well to volumeknob changes as well.
My amp reacts in a more tactile way.
Use Micro coils in my Ibanez s430, and L-500 C and L in my Ibanez R540, L-280's and a L-290 in the bridge of my CS Beck, have another old Ibanez lined up for my two L-90's, plus a L-280 in the middle.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

DreX said:
I love the tone and feel of Duckbuckers or vintage rails, they are the only noiseless vintage single coil style pickups I have installed.
Click to expand...

I really like them too. But I think the Classic Stack Plus has them beat.

One pickup that doesn't get the respect it deserves is the LiveWires Classic II; probably because they're active. But they certainly get the tone--and no hum.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

I've been happy with the Wilde Lawrence L-45s and the L-200 (L-290 in the bridge with that set).

As compared to regular single coils...well, which strat single coil variation are they supposed to be compared against?

There certainly isn't only "one" SC sound...however, while lines can blur, the difference between the strat SC sound and a full HB sound is very very distinct to me. Great sounds are not delegated to one of the other of course, but they're distinct.

I'm not a purist...I want a good tone. The Wilde pickups sound good and sound like SCs to my ears, and more than many other options do, from what I've listened to, etc. I work on my tone and playing the notes, from there...

I can understand that maybe these or other pickups just don't sound like what someone else has in their head as what they "should" sound like--good PAF style pickups often work that way for ME--but I like what I get with these, a lot.

Then again, some swear by this brand/model of SC and can't stand another that is even within the same ballpark... I might mention, I recently got an Ibanez Roadstar with 2 Ceramic SC's ~4.6k (and a Bridge HB I was using in split mod rather than HB mode). Tonally, that would have worked (minus inevitable hum, etc). I can make most SCs work. IMO...I use the tone control (and change the value as appropriate).

I myself simply cannot manage to play anything when my rig has that continuous awful hum even "behind" the notes--it distracts me so much, I don't even successfully focus on the music. Ideals about tone becomes moot at that point. The best SC tone in the world is useless to me as a player in that scenario. I might humbly say, more than I play guitar, more than I play a strat-style guitar(s), more than I play SC sounding pickups...I play music!

Thankfully, when I play the Wilde's, I don't mentally digress into there being something missing tonally or in their feel, so I can just play, sounds unmistakably like a Strat, and there isn't any dreadful hum going on. I suspect that sounds overly simplistic, or like I don't have ears, but I do...however, those pickups absolutely work for me.
 
Last edited:
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

Has anyone mentioned the Lace Holy Grails yet? Those are fantastic.
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

Stratman said:
I have tried way too many noiseless pickups from different manufacturers (Including Fender, Seymour Duncan, Dimarzio, and Lollar pups) and also have used the Suhr BPSSC.

It breaks down to two noiseless pickups from different manufacturers ...

Zexcoils - Fat Series

Kinman - Big Nine O
Click to expand...

Is there a particular reason that you used a type color that can't be read on the typical background color?!
 
Re: What are the absolute best noiseless strat pickups?

^I've been curious about that too. Do tell.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top