What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

yeti

New member
I've had a dilemma with the middle humbucker in my 3 HB guitar. I've tried a PG bridge, and a PG/Custom hybrid with various mags, and still end up a little on the muddy side. I'm thinking the safer bet might be trying a neck HB in that spot. I have an Alnico2Pro in the neck spot, so I'd like something very different, with its own voice in the middle spot. My first thought was a Jazz, but I'd like to hear some input from folks out there before my final decision. Something that splits well is would be a big bonus. :)
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

I love the PGn in my Standard. It's far from muddy...very articulate.
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

the Pearly Gates is my fav but I do love my Antiquity neck quite a bit as well. FWIW, you should go with a neck bucker in the middle position for sure. The PGn would be nice and articulate but still have plenty of body to the tone...help me out, whats in the neck and bridge spots and are you happy with them?

If you tried a PGb the PGn won't be a night and day difference but it will have a little less bass and low mids...an Alnico II Pro is a great pickup that would work well in the middle as is the Jazz...
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

I'd say Jazz, but I don't know how well it splits from experience because I don't have mine hooked up that way.
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

I dont think it gets much better than the Jazz, can do just about any style
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

Jazz splits well but may be a little hifi if you've EQed for the
rest of the guitar (Epi LP is a little dark and you've got A2 magnets
everywhere, correct?).

PGn does look like a good fit from the tone charts.

Stag Mag!

You said "splits well and is a little different", and Stag Mag
should do that in spades.

My original 3 pup plan was phat cats front and rear with stag
mag in the middle, still want to do something like that sometime.

disclaimer : of the pickups mnentioned I ave only used the Jazz
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

Stag Mag is a great choice. Has its own character, not muddy, born to split.
I've had three, and its my current favorite neck pup.

Artie
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

Jazz neck splits well from what I've tried, I prefer it when its not split, but when you wanna get it with a little less edge to it then its handy. I've only tried a split jazz in a mahogany body maple top guitar, so my opinion is limited, as for other pickups... I tried a stag mag once split, very nice, better then the jazz handled it. The jazz splits fine just the stag mag does it a lot better..
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

I don't like neck humbuckers...they're all to powerful and muddy for me unless played through a powerful amp at low volumes...like Wes Montgomery would've done.

But of those I've tried, I got the clearest tone from these:

Seth Lover neck
Pearly Gates neck
AIIPro HB neck
Antiquity neck
Jazz neck
Fralin 7.5K neck

I probably like the Seth Lover, PGn and Fralin 7.5K the best...
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

My favorite (that I've tried) is the LiveWire Classic, but I don't think that's a good option for you. I'm a pretty big fan of the Jazz. I like the 59, too.
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

madguitar26 said:
stupid question;could the pearly gates neck do jazz?

Of course. The PGn is just a version of a particular 50's Gibson paf humbucker that happened to be in a particular Les Paul guitar. They are all a little differant because they were all handwound and in those days they were not wound to tight tolerances. The PGn is not really that much differant than a Seth Lover or any other alnico 2 paf replica that tries to duplicate the sound of a '57 or '58 alnico 2 Gibson paf.
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

Wow, great input! Thanks guys. Trying to address all the suggestions, but just got home from the bar, so beer with me.
PGn-definitely in the running (i liked the bridge PG until BachtoRock got me hybrified) but i wonder if the slightly aggressive tone might make it sound like a wannabe bridge tone fighting a wannabe neck tone (it sounded that way with the PGb in the middle before i hybridized it).
The Jazz was my safe bet, until i considered the EQ factor mentioned by Frebnedzo - and who wants to play it safe, anyway?
Benjy, I hear ya, the Phat Cat would be a nice experiment, but i'm on an "everything must split, go parallel, etc." kick, so sticking with humbuckers until the madness passes :).
I was surprised to learn Lew's dislike of neck HBs, but then I never touched the things much until i put the Alnico2Pro in the neck. Nowadays I like to play bluesier stuff (for personal enjoyment) on the neck, and save the bridge hybrid for the flashier, in-your-face, balls out rocking. I've actually started to think of it as 2 personalities, the neck being an older, more mature and soulful sibling, while the bridge is a wild child, LOOK AT ME type sound. Not to say better players aren't getting "mature and soulful" out of the bridge, that's just how I feel at this stage in my playing. So far , for the middle HB, I've just gotten a "Jan Brady" sound, no stand out personality of its own.
I'm really curious about the Stag Mag (built to split,etc.), but I only see it listed as a bridge pickup. Are these really working for you in the neck, Artie?
The 16.2 rating would make for some great split sounds, but what does it sound like in full HB mode in a neck(ish) situation? I'm strangely intrigued...and slightly aroused :eek13: .
Thanks for all the input guys, and feel free to dog me out about my post-bar writing skills (yes, I made a Brady Bunch reference to describe tone ):smack: .
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

i hated the a2pro simply because i could not dial a very good jazz tone out of it.
the blues tone distorted is fenomenal but not my bag.
i wanted more output and more of a modern lead tone distorted and great clean for jazz (like the59).
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

yeti said:
I was surprised to learn Lew's dislike of neck HBs, but then I never touched the things much until i put the Alnico2Pro in the neck. .

I'm a Strat and Tele guy. :) But I do love soloing with a bridge humbucker.

Lew
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

I share Lew's opinion of the Fralin 7.5. I probably like it better than he does -- it is my favorite neck humbucker. The Jazz is a close second in my book.
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

Per Lew's advice a few years ago, I put a set of Antiquites in my 75 LP custom and never looked back. As far as the neck pickup goes, it is full yet not overbearing as a humbucker can be in a LP. Gotta learn to use the volume and tone knobs like I had to. Outstanding bluesy tone if that's what you want and sweet cleans.
 
Re: What are your favorite neck humbuckers?

yeti said:
I'm really curious about the Stag Mag (built to split,etc.), but I only see it listed as a bridge pickup. Are these really working for you in the neck, Artie?

I've found the SM to be a somewhat uninspiring bridge pup. "Ok", but everything else was better. However, as a neck pup, its killer. It doesn't have the "mud" thats so often associated with a neck humbucker. And of course, split, its even better. Its an almost perfect neck pup.

I'm using it in a Tele now. Its one of the very few guitars I have thats "set". That is, those pups will probably never change again. (The guitar underneath might upgrade, but those pups will stay together.) ;)

Artie

Keep in mind - I don't play professionally. Just a bedroom wanker.
 
Back
Top