Nite_Maresz_25
on Elm Streetologist
I see it whenever people are talking about a pickup's output, and I have no idea what the **** it is.
thanks
alex
thanks
alex
Several manufacturers list a mV of their pups, and you could measure them yourself, but it wouldn't tell you much unless you excited the pup the same way the factory did. Your pick attack, string size, and other factors are all going to effect your reading. But if you want to do it, make sure your mulitmeter is set to measure AC voltage. DC voltage would be totally worthless.Guitar Toad said:Does anyone ever take a mV measurement of their pups? What would that tell you?
JacksonMIA said:Several manufacturers list a mV of their pups, and you could measure them yourself, but it wouldn't tell you much unless you excited the pup the same way the factory did. Your pick attack, string size, and other factors are all going to effect your reading. But if you want to do it, make sure your mulitmeter is set to measure AC voltage. DC voltage would be totally worthless.
I'd be interested to see how the various manufacturers perform their tests, and if they're performed in such a way that you could compare them across brands.
I'd call it fun, but I'm an electrical engineer, a.k.a. nerd. I guess if you had a machine set up where you were reproducing the experiment exactly the same each time, you could use that to fine tune things...IF you knew what you were looking for.Guitar Toad said:Would you ever try to fine tune pup heights based off the determined mV? Perhaps just for fun? Would you call that fun?
JacksonMIA said:I'd call it fun, but I'm an electrical engineer, a.k.a. nerd. I guess if you had a machine set up where you were reproducing the experiment exactly the same each time, you could use that to fine tune things...IF you knew what you were looking for.
Are you saying something like test a PAF and then replace it with some other pup and adjust height and things until you got a match? If you kept everything else the same, I guess that would work. Of course, changing the height on a PAF would change the sound, so you'd be back to where you started.
Agreed. It would definitely be a neat experiment, but you're exactly right - the ear is best. Mostly because "perfect" tone to you is probably not "perfect" tone to me.Guitar Toad said:I posted a question about fine tuning pup heights based on the mV awhile back. Those that responded laughed and said just use your ears. They are a better guage since it's tone we're after more than output performance.
But, I still wonder about trying it some time just to see how much the pup output responds as the pup moves closer/farther from the strings.
Do you think pup output is inversely proportional to the pup to string distance? I think it would be a fun experiment. But, it likely wouldn't improve tone. The ear would certainly superior for tone.