What is you favorite PRS model and why?

'59

Active member
I've been playing a few PRS guitars: Vela, Mira, McCarty, and a Santana II. They were all phenomenal, but each had their own different thing going.

What is your favorite PRS model and why? Pictures and poetic responses would be appreciated.
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

I have a PRS SE II w/ soapbars. I like it because it was CHEAP.
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

Back around 2004/ 2005 I went to the big guitar show at the NEC indoor arena in Birmingham, UK. I did the usual browsing and trying various gear and came upon Paul Reed Smith doing to Q&A clinic, discussing his background and love of music, his aspirations and his aim to make the best guitars he possibly could. He spoke about the materials, construction and demo’d several models of that time trying to show the differences. For the most part he played his Personal guitar of the time which was essentially a McCarty with a full rosewood neck and a beautifully flamed maple top and choice select timbers. After he finished the Q&A he hung around talking to anyone who had any further questions and I was asking about his personal guitar and what really appealed to him about that one. He got the guitar back out of his beat up case and to be honest when he handed to me I was quite surprised how well used, almost beaten up this guitar was on close inspection. I asked why he isn’t using one of the newer, shiny spangly all singing all dancing guitars and he just said “this is my guitar”. He let me play it for a few minutes acoustically and I just fell in love, it was a nice weight, resonant and lively, felt and played fantastic. I asked if it was for sale and the answer was a solid no but they were production models just being built based on that guitar, it was the Modern Eagle.

Well to be honest when I actually saw them and the price tag it was out of the question at that time and for many years after. I had some very nice guitars at the time and more in the years following but I always aspired to getting an ME, nothing would stop me dreaming of those guitars. Then 4 years ago whilst browsing in a large guitar store in Birmingham I saw it, hanging on the wall and almost hidden out of the way. I had been going to that store for years and never saw this guitar, a Slate PRS with a matt finish looking quite plain against most of the other PRS offerings hanging on the wall. On closer inspection it dawned on me that I had my dream guitar in my hands. Satin nitro - check, thicker body - check..... Brazilian rosewood neck and board - check. Seriously, my heart was pounding trying to figure out how I was walking out of the store with this guitar.

After what felt an eternity I had a plan, I asked Gary (store manager who I had known for years) what he knew about the guitar as I was interested. He told me that the guitar had sat in the storeroom for nearly 10 years without ever being put on display. It WAS played at a PRS clinic that Paul did in 2005 but that was it. I had to ask how he could remember that and he said easy, I booked the PRS clinic and I booked Bernie Marsden who came along and played this guitar! After the clinic it went back in the suede case, in the protective cardboard box never to see the light of day until just a couple of weeks before that day when I saw it. I asked what he would accept and has it wasn’t in the stock due to it being hidden away for all those years, I made what I thought was a very cheeky offer and to my surprise he accepted due to my long term buying history with him. Well, I damn near crapped myself as it was still a lot of money and my better half would be quite pissed with me for spending so much on yet another guitar. My secret weapon, I was 50 in about 4 months time! I contacted her and she didn’t oppose it at all, so that day my dream guitar became a reality and to this day it’s still my dream guitar and the best guitar I’ve ever played. I have other great guitars including a couple of great LPs and a fantastic Tyler Strat type to name a few but the Modern Eagle is the one. I was very lucky.... here it is...


96E599DB-2222-4C10-8F41-6058F184F542.jpg
 
Last edited:
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

PRS SE Custom 22 chinese knock off with Fishman Tosin Abasi pickups...it was cheap, build quality excellent and the pickups are the best for cleans that I have ever heard...the low end on them is amazing...
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

I have 3 McCarty's that I like a lot. I like the simplicity. None of that 5 way rotary switch or whatever it is. I like the simple hardtail wrap around bridge too. Just my opinion. It works for me!
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

SE's do count for this exercise.

What sets the Modern Eagle apart from the Custom 22?

What are the main differences between the LP and its "evolution" the PRS McCarty 594?
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

The only one I own is an old SE One with an antiquity P90. I've played a couple 594 single cuts that were awesome guitars, as good as anything I've played.
 
Last edited:
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

d1dsj: Very cool story and gorgeous guit!

I have tried very few PRS' , as local shops normally dont carry that kind if high end gear. I have played several SE models. Thankfully, PRS' dont really trip my trigger. HOWEVER..... GC had a used one in there a few years back and I played it, and it was AMAZING!!!
I wish to heck I knew what model it was, cuz I could really go for one of those.. IIRC, the most enjoyable SE I ever played was a Dave Navarro sig. Really liked that one too..
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

d1dsj: Very cool story and gorgeous guit!

I have tried very few PRS' , as local shops normally dont carry that kind if high end gear. I have played several SE models. Thankfully, PRS' dont really trip my trigger. HOWEVER..... GC had a used one in there a few years back and I played it, and it was AMAZING!!!
I wish to heck I knew what model it was, cuz I could really go for one of those.. IIRC, the most enjoyable SE I ever played was a Dave Navarro sig. Really liked that one too..
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

I have a PRS KL 1812- it was a limited edition , only 100 made- essentially it’s an all Korina Custom 24 with no maple top, no trem, aluminum stoptail. It’s the best sounding guitar I have, it sounds like a cross between a Les Paul and Telecaster, especially with the coil tap. I got a good deal on it used and was lucky for how much I paid at the time. I’m hunting down a McCarty Korina once funds permit

The absolute best? In the 90s I played a PRS Signature Series Custom 24- according to Paul Reed Smith himself, these were private stock until he started the private stock program.

For their new guitars, I think the piezo system on their piezo equipped customs is the best sounding one out there.
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

SE's do count for this exercise.


What are the main differences between the LP and its "evolution" the PRS McCarty 594?

Shorter scale length by a fraction to make it easier to play . Stays in tune better due to the straight string pull of the headstock. Much better intonation than a Les Paul. Lower output pickups for a clearer tone, but the overall guitars construction gives more sustain and resonance to compliment the lower output pickups. Much better quality control.

Still saving for a 594 singlecut but I already have 2 les Paul’s
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

As someone who is new to the PRS world...if I was looking for a possible 22 fret guitar with a pretty top (but not super $ prices), which line should I look at?
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

As someone who is new to the PRS world...if I was looking for a possible 22 fret guitar with a pretty top (but not super $ prices), which line should I look at?

The S2 Custom 22 is good.

Personally though, I've been playing long enough that if I'm gonna buy something then I'm gonna save a buy the best... within reason... so I'd go full Custom 22 if it were me.
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

McCarty Singlecut 594 Goldtop

3 reasons why

1. It feels more resonant than reissues by Gibson
2. It preserves setup without going off at all for much longer than a popular Singlecut
3. The neck feels like you’ve played it for years from the get go


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

Back around 2004/ 2005 I went to the big guitar show at the NEC indoor arena in Birmingham, UK. I did the usual browsing and trying various gear and came upon Paul Reed Smith doing to Q&A clinic, discussing his background and love of music, his aspirations and his aim to make the best guitars he possibly could. He spoke about the materials, construction and demo’d several models of that time trying to show the differences. For the most part he played his Personal guitar of the time which was essentially a McCarty with a full rosewood neck and a beautifully flamed maple top and choice select timbers. After he finished the Q&A he hung around talking to anyone who had any further questions and I was asking about his personal guitar and what really appealed to him about that one. He got the guitar back out of his beat up case and to be honest when he handed to me I was quite surprised how well used, almost beaten up this guitar was on close inspection. I asked why he isn’t using one of the newer, shiny spangly all singing all dancing guitars and he just said “this is my guitar”. He let me play it for a few minutes acoustically and I just fell in love, it was a nice weight, resonant and lively, felt and played fantastic. I asked if it was for sale and the answer was a solid no but they were production models just being built based on that guitar, it was the Modern Eagle.

Well to be honest when I actually saw them and the price tag it was out of the question at that time and for many years after. I had some very nice guitars at the time and more in the years following but I always aspired to getting an ME, nothing would stop me dreaming of those guitars. Then 4 years ago whilst browsing in a large guitar store in Birmingham I saw it, hanging on the wall and almost hidden out of the way. I had been going to that store for years and never saw this guitar, a Slate PRS with a matt finish looking quite plain against most of the other PRS offerings hanging on the wall. On closer inspection it dawned on me that I had my dream guitar in my hands. Satin nitro - check, thicker body - check..... Brazilian rosewood neck and board - check. Seriously, my heart was pounding trying to figure out how I was walking out of the store with this guitar.

After what felt an eternity I had a plan, I asked Gary (store manager who I had known for years) what he knew about the guitar as I was interested. He told me that the guitar had sat in the storeroom for nearly 10 years without ever being put on display. It WAS played at a PRS clinic that Paul did in 2005 but that was it. I had to ask how he could remember that and he said easy, I booked the PRS clinic and I booked Bernie Marsden who came along and played this guitar! After the clinic it went back in the suede case, in the protective cardboard box never to see the light of day until just a couple of weeks before that day when I saw it. I asked what he would accept and has it wasn’t in the stock due to it being hidden away for all those years, I made what I thought was a very cheeky offer and to my surprise he accepted due to my long term buying history with him. Well, I damn near crapped myself as it was still a lot of money and my better half would be quite pissed with me for spending so much on yet another guitar. My secret weapon, I was 50 in about 4 months time! I contacted her and she didn’t oppose it at all, so that day my dream guitar became a reality and to this day it’s still my dream guitar and the best guitar I’ve ever played. I have other great guitars including a couple of great LPs and a fantastic Tyler Strat type to name a few but the Modern Eagle is the one. I was very lucky.... here it is...


View attachment 94194

I can attest that it is indeed a spectacular guitar, and partly the reason why I bought my 2005 McCarty as a gift to myself when I left the RAF 5 years ago.

1658262_10152285549272053_1545197378_o_zpsc7870fdd (1).JPG
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

As someone who is new to the PRS world...if I was looking for a possible 22 fret guitar with a pretty top (but not super $ prices), which line should I look at?

The S2 line have great 'bang for buck' US guitars. I tried a couple when I was shopping for my RAF retirement guitar, and was very impressed. Ultimately I was glad I shopped on and found my 2005 20th Anniversary 'core' McCarty that ticked those exact boxes Dave.
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

I like the Paul Weed Smith series myself.;)

48f286cdbb6c2b16a7ff450d1a22d0d8.jpg




;>)/
 
Re: What is you favorite PRS model and why?

A PRS Hollowbody II is the best guitar I've played in my life. Beyond outstanding in every aspect.

But in a more approachable realm, the PRS S2 Singlecut is a freakin' perfect guitar as it is.
 
Back
Top