Re: What size pot do you use on a HSS guitar?
In a guitar with only 2 pots to work with, would it be possible to use a 5 way superswitch to use a 500k tone and then drop the resistance of the tone to 250k when using the singles, using a resistor to drop the pot down to 250k?
Otherwise I like Mincer's idea with a traditional Strat style guitar with 3 pots.
I do have a strat with something similar.. in that it's a Lil 59 humbucker in the bridge, and two CS69's in the middle and neck. I use 250k master volume, and 250k tone for the neck, and 500k tone for the bridge. The middle pickup has no tone pot and is lowered a bit. Eric Johnson style. Except that the tone pot of the bridge has a push pull that puts the Lil 59 into series or parallel. Both options sound good to me, both in positions 1 and 2. In parallel, it has a bit of a Filtertron vibe.
The guitar works well, and the only thing is needing to drop the tone a bit on the bridge, when the Lil 59 is in parallel (5/10 on the tone pot). In series, 500k tone works well and I like it 7-9 out of 10. Even with 10/10, it's not overly bright. I'd imagine a 500k volume it'd also be good, in this case it doesn't seem to be required but it depends. There's always going to be tradeoffs. And this is a SC sized HB. For most full sized HBers, especially high output.. a 500k volume might be more preferred.