Re: Which Les Paul would you buy and why?
This is a total no brainer...
Forget clambering vs. solid vs. weight-relieved. It doesn't really matter, and neither do the myriad of other construction details, or what year it was made.
Neck shape does matter. Everyone has a preference, but you can adapt to almost anything, over time. The same can be said for color. Each of these guitar finishes have advantages and disadvantages.
For me, a hard case is a must, especially so for ANY Gibson. Gig bags are just asking for a broken neck if you are taking the guitar out. But aftermarket cases are available and are not very expensive, so it's not a huge issue.
There are often vast differences in Les Pauls, even among the same models. So the ONLY thing that really matters is which guitar speaks to you. It's a cliche, I know, but buy the one that puts a smile on your face. And be prepared to walk away from both of them, if neither feels "right". Internet opinions don't mean jack...you've got to make the best decision for YOU. And you are the only one who can decide that. Don't be afraid to play a lot of guitars.
Good luck.
Bill