Re: which would go best with a 59 in a lp
I like the C-5, since it's got supreme clarity under all levels of gain, and a tight percussive bottom end. I think you'd also like the Custom. Maybe you should install 2 of your top choices and return the 2nd fave. Try to use as many Duncans as possible in the bridge of your guitar, and you'll soon find the tone that's 'you.'