Re: Why can't I dig on Les Pauls?
Back in the early '70s when I was playing full-time, I could never bond with a Les Paul. My first electric was a Fender Duo-Sonic, and I have owned some kind of Leo Fender-made guitar (Fender, Music Man, G&L) my entire guitar life. For what I was doing, the HB pickups were too muddy, and the ergonomics of the control placement always seemed weird. The tone solution came in the form of an early '70s ES-330 Long Neck, and then 1975 '55 Special Re-issue, both with P-90s. But Customs and Standards remained foreign to me.
But in 2003, I got the opportunity to buy a 1995 Les Paul 1960 Classic Premium Plus and jumped all over it. It really hit the nail on the head, as I need a guitar with a thicker tone for some of the songs I was doing with my new band.
In some ways, it was a bad move--as I have become somewhat obsessed with Les Pauls and now own eleven of them. I have a '58 and '59 Historic, two of the Guitar Center 1960 Reissues, two Supremes, two of the 1960 Classics, two of the 2007 Guitar Of The Week Classic Antiques, and a Custom Shop Elegant. All of them get played, and all of them do gigs.
And the tone control placement still sucks, lol. It does take a different approach to playing them rather than my Number One G&L Legacy-bodied guitars, and I spent a lot of time just going to jam sessions with only the Pauls, to get used to handling them. I'm pretty comfortable with them now, up to a point; I play a Les Paul on about 12-15 songs a night with my band, and can easily switch back and forth between the Legacys and the Pauls, but I wouldn't play a Paul all night long. I also use ES-335s as my 2HB guitars, and they work well in that role, with some of the same issues.
SGs are also great guitars, but I'm a big guy and they look like a toy on me. Still I want one, and one of these days I'll find the one to add to my collection.
In 47 years of playing the guitar, I've learned that there are a few that work for me--and a lot that don't. So, I stick with what works. I do look at the pretty toys, but I tend to stick to what I know.
Bill