Re: Your tone 5 years ago and now (amps you've had).
Fender Ultimate Chorus (2x12", 130W, SS) - I gigged the bejeezus out of this amp - it has been all over the place with me playing venues as small as garages and as large as stadiums. Anyone who thinks all solid state amps are crap must not have spent much time playing clean through an Ultimate Chorus. Thick and rich.
VOX AD15VT (1x8", 15W, Hybrid) - I gigged this one every week for at least a year. I had a mic I carried everywhere with it, and gigged lots of places with this amp on the "UK 70s" setting and a dynamic mic out front. It is a true grab and go amp, and made gigging so much less of a pain in my ass, because all I needed was the guitar case and the amp. I loved the way it sounded, I made a hundred YouTube videos playing through it, and I still record with it because it just plain sounds good. Probably my favorite amp I have right now.
Blackheart BH5H Little Giant + Weber Blue Dog 12" (head/1x12", 5W, Tube) - I gigged this one probably only 5 times, I could just never get it to sound full and rich. It was too thin, and harsh, just kind of a thin sound all around. With a Tube Screamer, it would cop a good Strat neck+middle John Mayer style tone, but that's pretty much where the fun ended. Sounded bad with humbuckers, sounded bad with P90s, and this was in the height of my "EVERYTHING MUST HAVE P90s" phase. I ran a Weber MiniMASS attenuator with it, in hopes that opening up the throttle a little bit would make it sound better, but, to my not-so-surprise, it sounded fizzy, farty, and ****ty turned up - even without the attenuator. I traded it, cab, attenuator and all to a guy from TGP. For a...
Fender Hot Rod DeVille 212 (2x12", 60W, Tube) - Hilariously, I have never gigged this amp. 2x12" DeVilles are something like unicorns, in that most folks have never seen one in the wild --- most DeVilles are of the 4x10 variety. I like the way 12" speakers sound in these amps better than I like the sound of 4 10" speakers in these amps, so I hunted high and low to find a 2x12" variant. I am glad I did - it brings a lot of punch and low end. The bad news, is that the amp sounds kind of flat, for a big sexy tube amp. Not a lot of character. It sounds good, but not great, if you know what I mean. It does not inspire me to play more / better. It is loud, and clear though, it will absolutely rock your ass of with my good Monte Allums distortion box out front - very snarly and gut-punching. If I had to gig tomorrow, I would probably bring this amp, to justify my purchase (trade really, for a cheap ****ty amp I hated, so I guess it's a win), but I honestly like the crunch / drive tone of the VOX AD15VT better.
I will probably sell the Hot Rod DeVille and get some sort of a 6V6 amplifier next. I don't know - I am kind of disenchanted with amplifiers as a whole right now --- I haven't played anything that I liked in a real long time. I read a lot of bullcrap on the internet about what people love and why it's the best amp ever, but I honestly haven't played anything in a while that made me feel like playing more / better. Maybe I'll go in the opposite direction and try a Marshall.