Record it.
Things sound different when ya record them. Especially levels of gain. I just recorded some clips the other night, and had to back off my gain quite a bit cos it just sounds like too much. Also in the context of a song, things sound different..bass especially and drums make guitars sound beefier.
You can of course try to raise the pup too, and ya gotta make sure ya got an appropriate amp and guitar. Which Ibanez do you have? what body wood?
I could get very convincing "brown sounds" out of my 1987X with Heritage 150 and 59s believe it or not...
don't underestimate fingers and brain in the tonal chain!