Argggh, need help deciding...

AmirH

New member
I get my commission check in four days, and I gotta say- the time has finally come. I'm FINALLY buying my first tube amp. I picked up a marshall 1960a last week for 250(was even cheaper than I thought originally) and it's just screaming for a nice shiny head to go with it. HAS to be high gain, with gorgeous clean/smooth overdriven breakup and honestly after lots of testing it's come down to three choices-

Mesa rectoverb head(would be ordered with a tan colored grill for extra sexiness)- we don't have a head in the store but I've played the combo extensively. Sound wise, it absolutely vibes the best with me- it has everything I like about the recto sound and a lot less of what I dislike because it's a lot smoother sounding. On the vintage mode I was able to dial in some insanely sweet lead sounds, and the modern mode has the most punch of any amp I tried. I feel almost at home with this sound. The downside for me is the breakup on the pushed mode of the clean channel, and the overall "stiff" feel- it almost feels similar to playing a podxt. Don't mind this at all for rhythm- I actually prefer it. But for lead... man, I dunno. In any case this is the current front runner for me.

Mesa Mark IV- considering I would be special ordering the rectoverb this is about the same price. I haven't had a chance to play one and understand that while versatile they're EXTREMELY touchy/hard to dial in. I've also heard they don't record metal rhythm all that well (and I am NOT a fan of lamb of gods rhythm sound) which would frankly suck considering I'm completely sick of the podxt sound. That said, I've wanted one for as long as I've known about them and the idea of the mark lead sound alone is almost enough to sell me. But I mean, I wanted a prs too right until I got to play a bunch and realized I didn't care for the neck. Anyone with experience is MORE than welcome to give me the scoop on this thing.

Peavey jsx- I preferred this amp to both the xxx and 5150. The 5150 just doesn't sound like "me" at all, but the jsx was a lot closer with the same great fluid peavey feel. The feel more than anything else is what attracts me to this amp. I like the sound quite a lot but I also feel like it's a lot less natural sounding than the rectoverb or at least less like the sound I vibe with best. It has great clarity and punch, a good clean, and a great lead sound. It seems like this amp would feel great, sound great both live and recorded, but still never give me *EXACTLY* the sound I want. But maybe the virtues outweigh the one con- definitely the most plug and play amp of the bunch...

The greedy side of me wants to just slowly get all three and not have to make a decision, but I'd really like to get the right one first and not end up buying tons of amps. Give me your advice guys!
 
Re: Argggh, need help deciding...

I was in a similar position...over the course of two years, I now have a Mark IV head, Dual Rec head, and a Triple X 2x12.

It seems like you are looking for the recto sound with better cleans, that would be the Road King or the Roadster. The Roadster is in the same price range as a Dual Rec. Both are a little smoother than the Dual Rec (I have a Road King head on the way after playing one extensively)

The Mark IV is a strange beast. It has a very vintage vibe to me, the cleans have a little more spank than pure vintage clean tones and the the Lead channel is exactly that - phenomenal for leads. For rythm, well, the best example of that would be Metallica's And Justice For All...(I know they used Mark IIC's for that, but the pre-amp in the Mark IVa is the same pre with a power section). Plugging straight in and scooping the 5-band gets you there real quick. Very cool sound. Its is really flexible, but it doesn't have the sag of the recto series, or the singing low mids. Its very tight and articulate.

The Triple X and JSX are similar, with the JSX being a bit more toned down with some browner mids. Very modded Marshall, but misses just a little smack in the upper mids to be an extremely Marshall-esque sounding. I use the Triple X the least. More for jamming and its a 2x12 so it travels well. Its a very good sounding amp, but the Mesa's seem to record much better.
 
Re: Argggh, need help deciding...

Thanks man, anyone else wanna chime in? I think if I go the recto route it will definitely be the rectoverb... but I can see myself picking up all three in the not so distant future. Really I just wanna get the one that will make me completely happy first time around so that I don't blow more money.
 
Re: Argggh, need help deciding...

you said the Peavey JSX would be good but not give you exactly what you want... you also said the Rectoverb was great except you weren't sure about the lead tone. Since the Mesa vibes the best with you, I would say you should grab that; putting a boost in front of it like a TS9 or similar circuit makes a world of difference on a Recto I find.
 
Back
Top