Probably Mackie, but if it's a tight budget, the Behringer is basically a Mackie Chinese ripoff. I have one for my PA and it's lasted longer than any Carvin junk I've had.
The inexpensive Yamaha mixers are very nice. None of these have the best mic pres, but for the money you save with the Yamaha you can start saving for something like the FMR Audio RNP to run in front of it.