Re: Best guitar for a Fender Strat player to branch out with
If you are a pro or semi pro locked into a Number One, you really need to have a Number One-A...a guitar so close to your One that you can gig with it and and be perfectly comfortable with it. A must have.
I'm a Strat guy too, and since about 1994 my strat of choice is a G&L Legacy. But I also like 2HB tones, so I will use a Les Paul or ES-335 for 12-15 songs at a gig. But I would never want to do a four-hour gig with just a Gibson. But I do want a backup for my Legacy, so when I can I take another, third guitar to the gig, I take a G&L model called a Legacy Special. The LS has a set of dual blade HBs that can not only get me some PAF-ish tones, but the guitar's PTB tone controls get me close to vintage alnico tones too....the perfect backup to both my Legacy and my Paul...Strat ergonomics and some nice thick tones too.
So consider the Legacy Special. If you like the idea of a clone of your MIM Strat, you could try modifying it with a different pickup set, switching and/or tone controls to contrast with your main guitar, while keeping the same ergonomics and feel.
I like gigging with both Legacy and a Paul/335. I love the variety of tones, and the shorter Gibson scale also comes in handy on some songs. I can easily adapt to the neck difference, but the Gibson switch and control placement can make me a little uncomfortable. It's worth it to me, but you may find that a clone of your Strat with a hot pickup set may be what you're looking for.
But beware, the concept of the "one guitar that can do it all" is a myth...it doesn't exist. So by all means, a second guitar is good to have. Then the trick is to have the right guitar for each song.
Good luck!
Bill