Re: Best HB for 80's hard rock/hair metal?
I've tried a few of the so-called "80s metal" pickups, and I thought that I would post my insights...
For early 80s rock, you cannot go wrong with the JB. It easily mimics many of the bands that hit the scene around this time. The sound has more of a balanced edge to it without being too unrefined or over-the-top, and not so overly processed as many hits from the later 80s (think Poison and Winger). Two bands that easily come to mind that represent the JB are Queensryche and Ratt. For a fact, I know that Michael Wilton uses a JB in his signature ESP model, and both Robbin Crosby (who the Jackson "King V" is named after) and Warren DeMartini used the JB model throughout their time with Ratt. I have the JB in one of my guitars, and absolutely love/swear by it!
Another pickup that is great for the early 80s period is the Duncan Distortion. It has all the characteristics of the JB, with the exception of a ceramic magnet, and is more "raw" and has better cut and definition, especially on the low E string. As the back of the packaging says, it's made for "raw and distorted" rock sounds, and this couldn't be more true. Whenever I think about the Distortion, the first song that pops into my head is "Breaking the Chains" by Dokken (granted, Lynch did use that pickup throughout most of his career). If you're looking for a pickup that really pushes the amp hard, then your search has ended! It's not my favorite pickup as it's more aggressive than I prefer for playing, but it certainly has its place in one of my guitars.
If you're wondering about the later 80s, well, I couldn't forget the Full Shred model. I recently picked one of these up, and I'm absolutely in love with it! It has to be one of the crunchiest pickups I've ever played, and the low-end really comes through easily, yet with clarity, with even the most brutal palm muting or tremolo picking. The sound is extremely defined and tight, even though it has decreased output compared to the JB and Distortion (Seymour Duncan classifies it as "medium output", but it's borderline to high output, if you ask me). If your chops are not so up to snuff, then you'll know about it soon enough! However, for those with experience in playing faster styles and knowing how to properly control their guitar with correct/accurate technique, you will feel right at home.
So what's the best for you? I couldn't say for sure, as we all have our own perception of the "perfect tone". My suggestion is to try to play at least all three, and let your own ears be the judge. At $70 a piece, you're really not out too much if you decide to keep one or two in a drawer somewhere for a later date.
Hope this helps, and keep on rockin' Seymour Duncan style!