Best Pickups to match a JD in a Nashville Telecaster

Seth Pearly

New member
I've had an Ash Nashville Deluxe Telecaster for the last 6 months. I bought it as my first foray into fender single-coil quacking, clucking and twanging. For the last 20 years, I have been playing on HH guitars (Gibson, Epiphone and Carvin). On this guitar, I've been playing a mix of blues, classic rock, modern and indie rock - a fairly wide gambit as its a flexible guitar. For those who aren't as familiar, the Nashville comes with 3 pickups and a standard 5-way switch in a strat configuration. The stock pickups are all A5 "Tex-Mex" - a tele bridge, strat middle and tele neck.

So far, I have had a blast on the guitar. I have been pleased with the tex-mex neck, and the middle works to give me very useable 2/4 "in between tones", but I've had a hard time falling for the stock bridge pickup. When the tone control is up its ice-picky, and when down, it gets muddly/dead quickly. I have replaced the vintage 6-saddle with a callaham vintage bridgeplate/3 comp saddles. That's helped with sustain, and cut some of the overbite down but it's still very thin when clean. Based on the reviews I've seen, the Jerry Donahue seems to be the pickup to go to (at least for now). In the classic tele spectrum, but more growly (lower-mids) and less pure twang - that works really well for me.

I have read, however, that Fender and SD pickups don't always play well, and looking for suggestions on the neck and middle pickups. In an ideal world, this guitar will sound more like a tele when I'm playing closer to the bridge, and more like a strat as I move to the neck. The nashville has the swimming pool route, so I'm not really limited to classic tele neck-sized pickups (I'll just change the pickguard). I'm also going to be adding a mini-toggle so I can get the Neck+Bridge combo.

As a reference, one of my favorite neck tones of late has been John Mayer's live sound on "Where the Light Is"

I am open to a wide variety of suggestions, though I think right now I'm probably looking at staying in the strat/tele single coil mode, as opposed to adding a 'bucker, mini or P90...

thank you in advance for any suggestions!
 
Re: Best Pickups to match a JD in a Nashville Telecaster

the only reason fender and duncan pups dont always work is they are out of phase. usually that can be fixed by flipping some wires around and maybe moving a ground. id start with one pup and see how that goes. the jd is a great pup.

ssl1 would be my suggestion for neck and middle pups if you want classic strat tones
 
Re: Best Pickups to match a JD in a Nashville Telecaster

the only reason fender and duncan pups dont always work is they are out of phase. usually that can be fixed by flipping some wires around and maybe moving a ground. id start with one pup and see how that goes. the jd is a great pup.

ssl1 would be my suggestion for neck and middle pups if you want classic strat tones

I love my JD-it's my all time favorite tele pickup and probably my all time favorite period! The thought of swapping it out never crossed my mind. I started of with an aps-2 in the middle and couldn't really get a good quack, so I swapped for an ssl-1 and that did the trick. I run it with a Fralin Blues Special in the neck. There is some phase issues and I have hum in the neck/mid pos, but I don't care-it's there in pos 1,3 and 5 too!

I think ssl-1 n and rw/rp mid with a JD will make that guitar work really great for you!
 
Re: Best Pickups to match a JD in a Nashville Telecaster

I love my JD-it's my all time favorite tele pickup and probably my all time favorite period! The thought of swapping it out never crossed my mind. I started of with an aps-2 in the middle and couldn't really get a good quack, so I swapped for an ssl-1 and that did the trick. I run it with a Fralin Blues Special in the neck. There is some phase issues and I have hum in the neck/mid pos, but I don't care-it's there in pos 1,3 and 5 too!

I think ssl-1 n and rw/rp mid with a JD will make that guitar work really great for you!

I'm looking forward to getting the JD.. I've heard great things about the Fralin Blues in the neck. How do you like that pickup? The problem I'm running into are that most Tele necks are rw/rp to humcancel in the middle of a two-pickup Tele. It's why I've been thinking of replacing the Tele neck with a strat neck pickup and just swapping the pickguard.
 
Re: Best Pickups to match a JD in a Nashville Telecaster

The problem I'm running into are that most Tele necks are rw/rp to humcancel in the middle of a two-pickup Tele.

Weird. Depends on where you are looking, I guess. I think that from the SD line only the A2Pro and 5/2 are rw/rp. It should only be a shop floor custom to get them non rw/rp as well if that's a deal breaker.
 
Re: Best Pickups to match a JD in a Nashville Telecaster

Weird. Depends on where you are looking, I guess. I think that from the SD line only the A2Pro and 5/2 are rw/rp. It should only be a shop floor custom to get them non rw/rp as well if that's a deal breaker.

Funny - those were the two I was looking at :) I'll take a closer look at the rest of the line...
 
Back
Top