Re: Best weight for a Les Paul? Whats your thoughts?
Customs always sounded harder to my ear too. I think it may be the ebony boards. The only two I ever bonded with were a 1972 '54 reissue, and a '76 with DiMarzio PAFs that warmed the tone considerably.
I prefer LPs in the 8-9 lb range, mainly because heavier ones tire me out quickly now that I'm pushing sixty. And I often find it's the lighter guitars that sing more freely at volume. My take on this is that it may simply require less ambient sound energy to get them vibrating fully, compared to ones that weigh more.
Tone is a more important consideration for me than weight though- balanced response or scooped is OK with me, but I couldn't deal with a big mid spike like the one some_dude described.
Still, for me the biggest factor is liveliness, particularly in the neck. This is where long tenon guitars have a real advantage. I love to feel the vibrations humming under my hands, from an axe that really comes alive in my arms. It's gotten to the point now that I'll tap the back of a headstock and can usually tell from the way it shivers whether the guitar is going to suit me in terms of liveliness. Then I'll check out the neck feel, tone, weight, etc. after that. There haven't been many Les Pauls that passed the shiver test and didn't sound good. The lively ones mostly sound great. In fact, I'd have to say that most LPs seem to have pretty good natural tone; in my experience there have been very few genuinely dead logs among them, and I've never owned a Standard that had real midrange problems. Of course I'm partial to open-sounding pickups too; some of my LPs might not sound as good as they do if I were using pickups with a more congested character.
My #1 Les Paul weighs in at 8.1 lbs. Not sure whether it's lost any weight over the years, since I didn't weigh it when I got it 33 years ago. But I keep them pretty well humidified so it likely isn't any lighter than it was. My others range from 7.8 to 8.9 lbs, not counting the LP Special and an SG-style LP Custom which are lighter. Heaviest guitar I own is a '72 Ibanez lawsuit Jazz Bass that tips the scales at nearly 12 lbs. Man, that thing is a beast!