Buy/Sell advice

jimpmiller

New member
i was in GC the other day checking out amps, and i cant keep my eye off this black 72 les paul. its pretty dinged up. has a crack about 1/9th an inch deep in between the pickups and the crack continues all the way down the guitar. not on the neck though. this is a 1972 custom shop. it has gold hardware. plays like a dream. should i sell my 04 sg twards it? the origonal price was 1500 and the manager came down to 1100. i have always wanted a les paul and my dad could re-finish it but im kind of skeptical of selling an almost beand new sg for something that has been around the block a few times. any advice?
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

I wouldn't buy a cracked guitar even if it was glued and repaired professionally. Makes it a real hard sell if you want to sell it again someday. Lew
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

Lewguitar said:
I wouldn't buy a cracked guitar even if it was glued and repaired professionally. Makes it a real hard sell if you want to sell it again someday. Lew

+1
I agree too that the resale of the guitar will not be as great. I don't have any experience with buying broken/repaired guitars because i am one of those guys that's too afraid that if I buy a $1500 guitar that's been repaired it will break again and I'm out $1500. I know that repairs can be done very solid, but it's just my own gut feeling!! Besides I very very rairly buy guitars from retail stores. I don't like paying sales tax or markup. However sometimes you do find a deal.
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

And having your dad refinish it would further lower the value.....

I´m a luthier and even I rarely buy broken and/or repaired guitars on purpose... and even then I would prefer broken to previously repaired...

If you´re not sure you want to keep this guitar forever, I´d pass, save another few bucks, and get a Standard in good condition ;)
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

Lewguitar said:
I wouldn't buy a cracked guitar even if it was glued and repaired professionally. Makes it a real hard sell if you want to sell it again someday. Lew

+1 Don't bother.
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

Keep the SG and don't buy the broken Les Paul.....Pagey wouldn't want you to do it! lol
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

And on the flip side.....

Guitar Center is notorious for charging way too much for vintage gear. At least around here they are. Tell the manager you've got a "friend" who picked up a 72 deluxe with a repaired neck for $800. Got it off ebay no less about a year ago and I don't regret it one bit. It's the "nicest Paul I've ever played", which of course only means it's the one that I prefer over all the others I've played.

Here's the scoop--and as always, it's just an opinion--If you've played it, you love it, YOU'RE PLANNING ON KEEPING IT, and you don't mind the crack, I'd walk in with cash and try to get it for around the same $800 I paid. Bottom line is it's only worth what it's worth to you. I happen to like the early seventies Les Paul guitars better than anything later.

Everyone else is right. It will be hard to sell and a refin will lower the value even more. I feel I got awful lucky with mine as it was sight unseen, but it was an impulse buy and I just had a feeling. I'm a Page fanatic and really wanted a cherry sunburst LP, and the bridge pickup was re-routed for a humbucker (another value killer) so I went for it. I would see if they would let you buy it with a ten day or so trial with a full money back guarantee so you can bring it to a guitar tech and get an opinion as to whether it's gonna split in two or what. Your dad may be a great woodworker or refinisher, but an instrament luthier is a different animal as they (a good one) know about the stress the strings put on the body and how this crack will affect the tone. Good luck, hope I helped out a little. :smoker:
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

75lespaul said:
If you've played it, you love it, YOU'RE PLANNING ON KEEPING IT, and you don't mind the crack, I'd walk in with cash and try to get it for around the same $800 I paid. Bottom line is it's only worth what it's worth to you

bottom line above all else if u love it after all said and done then its worth it especially if u can knock that price down and something is only worth as much as 1 is willing to pay for it

ps caution: my friend gave me his guitar and it had a crack in the neck and it had a good sound but the crack took out some of the sustain and made it go out of tune more frequently
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

I'm a Page fanatic and really wanted a cherry sunburst LP, and the bridge pickup was re-routed for a humbucker (another value killer) so I went for it. I would see if they would let you buy it with a ten day or so trial with a full money back guarantee so you can bring it to a guitar tech and get an opinion as to whether it's gonna split in two or what.


guitar centert has a 30 day money back thing
 
Re: Buy/Sell advice

i went to guitar center again and the scratch is only finish deep, we checked. still dont know if i want to trade in the sg, however.
 
Back
Top