cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

I agree. I've had good luck with both the JB and Distortion. Yes, the guitar you put it in definitely matters. Back in the late 80sI popped a JB out of a Kramer Baretta and popped it into an original early 80s Charvel Strat and took the Distortion out of that Charvel Strat and popped it into the Kramer and both axes sounded incredible afterwards. I had a custom made strat in the late 80s as well. It had a 22 fret ebony fretboard with stainless steel medium/large frets on a wide maple neck with Schaller locking tuners and an American Standard style double fulcrum non-locking trem set plush, and alder body, a frontal jack like a Strat, a single volume that if you pulled up switched to a backslanted Quarter Pounder in the neck. The bridge was a Distortion. It was an INSANELY toneful guitar. Amazing. It had the sustain and power of a Les Paul and the snap of a Strat and it was black and so was the headstock. Great ax. As for the JB, I think it's one of the best pups you can put in a Les Paul. It's an incredible combination that lets the LP shine through while adding something special. I say if you want to bring out the best in an LP or SG pop in a JB. As for strat style axes, depending on the wood, I would go with a Distortion, JB, or Custom. What I love about the Custom is that it gives you that half open wah/Michael Schenker tone that you hear in a lot of DiMarzios without the drawbacks of DiMarzios. But the JB is pretty much a desert island pup. I love the Distortion but know the JB has a more universal tone for most players.
 
Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

Oops! Sorry. I've used the Super Distortion as well. I think it's a good pickup and I can't deny its historic significance. It was quite a phenomenon in the 70s. My preference is the JB over the Super Distortion. The Super Distortion was created with a different design philosophy. When it went into mass production in 1974 the average amp needed to be kicked into overdrive with a high output pup and the amp needed to be cranked to get a real grinding sound. The JB, also a high output pickup, was a lot more balanced between distortion and sustain and was legendary by the time it went into mass production, in big part do to its associated with Jeff Beck, hence JB, although Seymour says it stands for Jazz and Blues. Well, the JB works well with everything, including jazz and blues. I find that the Super D can be a bit thin sounding with high gain amps. I've had much better luck getting a good smooth sound with chord clarity from high gain amps with the JB. The axes I had that came with Super Ds were a BC Rich Mockingbird and a Yamaha SG I got used which was loaded with Super Ds. I sold the Mockingbird and Switched the Super D's in the Yamaha with a Duncan Custom in the Bridge and a '59 in the neck. Sounded fantastic. I would say if you want a high distortion pup I lean heavily towards the Duncan Distortion. But I'd take the JB over a Super D any day. Just works better for me.
 
Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

Trying to get a custom shop Charvel in the H-S configuration. The neck will likely be a quarter pounder and for the bridge I waffle between a Demartini-RTM-JB or the Dimarzio Super Distortion.

I am a huge fan of Ratt and Def Leppard and know I'll be happy with either pickup in the bridge but since the guitar will pack a Floyd Rose, Alder Body with quilted maple top and maple neck I thought I would add this to the confusion to see if there is any feedback as far as NOT going one way or the other.

Thanks rocker-peeps.

NC

In this situation, RTM all the way. Not that a SuperD would be bad. That guitar is JB-style all damn day.
 
Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

So - 9 years later and my answer for this thread: Still Super Distortion.

I think the JB is just damn fine pickup and very flexible. It definitely has an edge as a "lead" pickup. And it is also pretty darn ok overall for blues, rock, pop, metal etc. It is nothing with the pickup itself. It's really that I just love the Super Distortion sound better. Thicker, tighter, more even voiced. It's just more of what I personally like.
 
Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

So - 9 years later and my answer for this thread: Still Super Distortion.

I think the JB is just damn fine pickup and very flexible. It definitely has an edge as a "lead" pickup. And it is also pretty darn ok overall for blues, rock, pop, metal etc. It is nothing with the pickup itself. It's really that I just love the Super Distortion sound better. Thicker, tighter, more even voiced. It's just more of what I personally like.
Nice man. I'll say the same thing for myself, but the opposite. I'm a JB guy and it messes me up when I see people saying they don't like it - in my opinion it's the best pickup ever made. But it's probably more that it just speaks to ME as an individual. Something about that sort of thin tone, and intense midrange grind , the fact that it sounds vintage and modern at the same time, allows me to get the sound I'm hearing in my head, and many others, out of this pickup. Its the only pickup I could play ANY genre with, because I just gel with it so perfectly - my fingers just kinda know what to do when I have a JB plugged in, at any gain level.. I even love its clean tone.

It's like an old friend that knows everything about me and is always there for me. And I guess it's true that I've been playing the JB for about 16 years now with various flirtations with other setups. The one album I ever recorded that people bought, I recorded when I was on a big Invader kick. I like other pickups a lot too, big fan of full shred and custom , even a big fan of the '59, and I definitely do like the super distortion (one word I would use to describe it is "huge"). There's even been a few times I fell in love with the EMG sound and swore I'd use them for the rest of my life.(and I recorded some damn good pieces with them, can't lie) but nothing, and I mean nothing, can ever replace my beloved JB. I always have and probably always will come back to the JB. It just sounds "right"

Sent from my SM-G965W using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

I'm thinking if I were in a hard blues blues/rock band, I'd want a JB that let me run from clean to mean on the amp.

But I don't really use clean. I'm more of a mean to meaner guy....
 
Re: cage fight - JB vs. Super Distortion?

I vote Tone Zone. :P



But I'm usually a neck pickup guy, and usually play clean more than distorted.
 
Back
Top