Re: Cannibal corpse what pups?
And the studio engineer and mixing console and outboard studio gear they used, and the live soundguy and board and other gear they used....
Do people really believe these tones are achieved in a straight line of "guitar>amp>CD", or that getting the pickups someone else uses will?
What you're hearing is not their guitars, pickups, and amps captured on disc. You're hearing their guitars, pickups, and amps once they've been processed to fit in the situation (recording or live).
Here's why the pickup you choose will not matter all that much:
The stereo/ipod/walkman/cd player you listen to has its own voice, so you're hearing the stereo's interpretation of the 1s and 0s on the CD which were put there by the duplicating house, who took the 1s and 0s from a digital tape also containing 1s and 0s, which was mastered on a computer that translated electrical impulses into 1s and 0s according to a specific formula that states x impulse = nnnn series of 1s and 0s.
This is driven by a codec (code/decode driver/program). Different codecs translate electrical impulses into 1s and 0s differently, and thus have their own voice.
The digital tape recorder is only repeating what the mastering software told it.
Computer audio hardware is also driven by a codec, and usually, not the same one as used by the mastering program that put those 1s and 0s on the digital tape.
Ergo, that has its own voice, so the mastering software is repeating the what the audio hardware told it.
Mixing consoles (both live and studio) have their own voice, so studio recording computers/live PA systems are hearing the mixing console's interpretation of what's coming through the mic.
PA speakers have their own voice, so in a live situation, you're hearing the speaker's interpretation of what the mixer hears from the mics.
Mics have their own voice, so the mixing console is hearing the mic's interpretation of the sound coming from the speakers in the amp cabinet, each of which has its own voice.
The speakers' voice coil and cone and frame are reacting to electrical impulses from the amp head.
These reactions cause the speaker to flex, which causes the cabinet to vibrate, which then loops back into the frame of the speaker and to the spring-like cone, where certain vibration frequencies are either amplified (doubled, tripled, etc), muffled (halved, quartered, etc), or muted (outgoing frequency meets incoming frequency of the same magnitude and cancel each other out).
The material, material density, and construction of the cabinet influences the cabinet's vibration, and therefore how it is fed back into the speakers. As well, the acoustic properties of the cabinet contribute to the sound the mics hear, which is also colored by the material, material density, and construction of the cabinet.
The sound coming out of the cabinet is a mix of the sound from the speaker itself, the sound that is reflected off the inside of the cabinet and bounced back out the front (where the largest ports are), and the cabinet's vibrational influence on the speakers.
The speakers are translating electrical impulses from the amp head, which is receiving electrical impulses from the pickups in the guitar.
The circuitry in the amp translates incoming impulses to outgoing impulses, and which parts of each impulse are changed along the way, and how they're changed. This is the amp head's voice.
So, the speakers are hearing the head's interpretation of the pickups in the guitar.
The mic is hearing the cainet's interpretation of the head's interpretation of the pickups' interpretation of the vibration of the strings and guitar body.