Re: DiMarzio Virtual Hot PAF
papersoul said:
I am interested in this vhPAF, but I always heard that Dimarzios were never as thick sounding or as clear as Duncans....not the same quality so I have always avoided them! But, now the interest is there.
:banghead:
Arrgghh...It's a magnet, a bobin(or 2) and some WIRE!!!!
I know different pickups sound different...but it's largely due to a combination of three factors ===>
* the gauge wire used
* the type of magnet used
* the amount of winds of above mentioned wire
I know that's a gross overgeneralization.....but if you boil it down to 3 basic factors, the above applies. There's also techniques that some pickup manufacturers use that also affect the way a pickup sounds...Dimarzio's 'air' spacing comes to mind...
But the fact of the matter is that, 99% of the time passive pickups are just bobbins wrapped with wire around or above a magnet. Thats it...
So to make a gross generalization that dimarzios are muddy or Duncans are ear-piercingly bright is rediculous. Both companies have bright pups and dark pups....
This topic really bothers me because it's been abused by boutique pup winders and fans of boutiquers. They'd love to have you believe that hand winding the thing makes for a better pickup (no, just a more unpredictable one)...before long you're going to see them selling pickups that have actual fralin or detemple sweat dropped into the bobbin...that'll be a 40 dollar upcharge, I'm sure!
I've tried dimarzios that I thought were muddy...but if that generalization were true, then the company, by that generalization should have never made the 'Air Norton'. The 'Air Norton' is a mid gain pickup...with a DC resistance of 12.5K...you'd think in the neck, it would be mud city. In the neck of a guitar, this pickup is strong and as crystal clear as a bottle of spring water.
I'm sorry to sound like I'm ranting....I really do...
Unfortunately, a little mystique around a particular pickup or manufacturer is what sells replacement pups. But the fact of the matter is that it's a tool...it's one part of a guitar that gets you the tone you need.
Look to each pup manufacturer, boutique (fralin, detemple, lollar), specialty (SD, Dimarzio) or guitar (fender, gibson)....individually. If a particular guitar sounds good with stock fender pups, don't argue...just play the thing till it dies in your hands. If a Duncan pup sounds good in you axe....don't argue, play your guitar....same with Dimarzio...or Fralin, etc, etc...
But trust me, every pup manufacturer has bright and dark pickups....