Re: Duncan / Dimarzio Mixes
I've combined a Norton with a Pearly Gates; a Super Distortion with a 59er; a Custom with a PAF; a Class of 55 with SSL-1s. My experiences were all the same: Both brands had their overall signature sounds but they just didn't play nice together. It was like having high end OEM pickups in the guitars. By this I mean, I constantly found myself tweaking my amps to either the DiMarzios or the Duncans and naturally, that wound up in a lot of tonal compromise with either brand which by necessity, caused my whole sound to suffer.
I will say this though: Duncan makes MANY more models which are perfectly compatible to my stylings and I'm quite satisfied with the ones I use. As a whole, yes, I prefer Duncans by leaps and bounds. However, with the very FEW DiMarzios I do like, I prefer them better than their Duncan counterpart(s). Naturally, this is my experience/opinion and YMMV.