Gibson 137 or Robin

[DotNetTim]

Hey guys.. Anyone want to help me figure out which guitar you'd buy? Just cuirous.. Here are the specs.. I think I could get both guitars at about the same price, so price not being calculated in the equation, which guitar seems at least better to you folks?

Robin Guitar!

Savoy Pro

* Semi-hollow mahogany body with solid maple carved arched top, f-holes
* One piece mahogany set neck,22 jumbo frets, 24 & 3/4" scale
*
* Rio Grande Barbeque & Genuine Texas Humbucking pickups Master volume and tone, 3-way switch
* Mother of pearl dots in rosewood fingerboard
* Tunamatic bridge & stop tailpiece, nickel plated hardware
* Vintage Yellow and Cherry finishes in satin
* Quality Hardshell Case

List Price: $1795.00


Gibson Guitar:
ES-137P with Humbuckers
Manufactured in: Memphis, TN

BODY
Size: 16" wide x 20" long x 2.25" thick
Top Species: Maple/Poplar/Maple laminate
Back Species: Maple/Poplar/Maple laminate
Rim Species: Maple/Poplar/Maple laminate
Center Block Species: 1-piece Mahogany
Binding: Single-ply black on top and back

NECK
Species: Maple
Profile: 1960 slim-taper
Peghead Pitch: 14°
Thickness at 1st fret: 0.818"
Thickness at 12th fret: 0.963"
Heel Length: 0.625"
Neck Joint Location: 16th fret

FINGERBOARD
Species: Rosewood
Scale length: 243/4"
Total Length: 18"
Nut Width: 111/16"
Width at 12th fret: 2.062"
Frets: 22
Inlays: Half trapezoids with 'P' inlay at the 12th fret
Binding: Single-ply black

HARDWARE
Plating Finish: Chrome
Bridge: Tune-o-matic
Tailpiece: Stopbar
Knobs: Black Speed
Tuners: Green Key

ELECTRONICS
Neck Pickup: 496R humbucker
Bridge Pickup: 500T humbucker
Controls: Two volume, two tone, three-way switch

CASE
Exterior: Black smooth levant hardshell
Interior: Charcoal Plush
Silkscreen: Gold 'Gibson' logo

STRINGS
Brite Wires .010-.046

OTHER

 

[\m/(00)\m/]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

robin definitely, would you want a lamintated top or a solid maple top?

 

[Maggot]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

Robin definitely. It's more unique, and the Gibson is lower-level Gibson, and I've definitely been disappointed in their quality control in the past, where the Robin is a top of the line Robin.

 

[kaknight]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

i'd go robin too. sounds like a much higher quality guitar, just without the "gibson" name!

 

[DotNetTim]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

I'd think one would want the Solid top, but to be honest I don't know the difference.. I do know that my fav guitarist of all time is Ted Nugent of course who used lot's of Gibson Semi Hollow body Jazz boxes.. and he could milk notes out of that puppy! hehe

Tim

robin definitely, would you want a lamintated top or a solid maple top?

 

[Mincer]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

also check out older Gibson Howard Roberts Fusions, either from the early 90s or from the early 80s (different design back then)...some great deals to be found.

 

[Scott_F]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

I'd skip both of them and go straight for a Heritage 535 and get that classic double cutaway 335 look and that AWESOME Sound that will smoke the 137 and the Robin.

Just my two cents.

 

[That90'sGuy]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

also check out older Gibson Howard Roberts Fusions, either from the early 90s or from the early 80s (different design back then)...some great deals to be found.

My girlfriend's uncle let me play his original HRF Gibson and it is an UNBELIEVABLE guitar for jazz fusion. It really sounds great and it looks and feels great. I didn't think that I'd ever be blown away by a Gibson like that, but I was.

 

[TattooedCarrot]

Re: Gibson 137 or Robin

I believe all semi-hollows and hollows need to use laminates and cannot use solids on the body because of the shaping that's required (except for the center block). You can bend a laminate but cannot bend solid wood. I just bought a Gibson ES-137 Classic in blueburst and it's a great guitar. I know nothing of the Robin.