If I decide to plunk down $150-160 on a Duncan Custom Shop pickup, I'm down to one of these two. It's going into a "rock" esquire-- single bridge humbucker tele body, alder, with a strat hardtail bridge, single 250K pot, maple neck & fretboard.
Here's a little background. I'm a tele lover, but dig a great rock sound. Classic hard rock tones to me are DLR-era Van Halen, Guns & Roses, old Dokken & Ratt, Kiss, Bon Scott era AC/DC. That sort of "kerrang" to a good power chord. Pissed off, bitey, but still big sounding and not real compressed. I play through an older (91-92) tweed Bassman Reissue (first year, I believe) w/ the channels jumpered, and a decent dirt box. That's it. My other guitars are a Super Distortion equipped strat (fat sounding) and a tele with a Duncan Broadcaster in the bridge.
Given my gear choices and musical & fave band choices, which would be a more appropriate fit-- the '78 or the S-Deco?
I've seen the S-Deco here being described as the "Brobucker killer". I've read a couple reviews on the '78 as being very, very "pissed off" sounding. I think I've ruled out the Brobucker as the other two seem to be brighter and more aggressive sounding (the '78 definitely). I've checked into the new EVH frankenstein humbucker, but at 14.4K and A2 and a little more compressed than it's predecessor the '78, it seems pretty similar to a CC, so I've ruled it out too.
I've not played either (well, any, if we're including the Brobucker), and I've already done alot of reading here. Without saying what i'm already leaning towards, I thought I'd ask for a little more direction & opinions here.
Also, does the Custom Shop do relicing and is it included in the $160 price tag?
Your advice is most appreciated!
Here's a little background. I'm a tele lover, but dig a great rock sound. Classic hard rock tones to me are DLR-era Van Halen, Guns & Roses, old Dokken & Ratt, Kiss, Bon Scott era AC/DC. That sort of "kerrang" to a good power chord. Pissed off, bitey, but still big sounding and not real compressed. I play through an older (91-92) tweed Bassman Reissue (first year, I believe) w/ the channels jumpered, and a decent dirt box. That's it. My other guitars are a Super Distortion equipped strat (fat sounding) and a tele with a Duncan Broadcaster in the bridge.
Given my gear choices and musical & fave band choices, which would be a more appropriate fit-- the '78 or the S-Deco?
I've seen the S-Deco here being described as the "Brobucker killer". I've read a couple reviews on the '78 as being very, very "pissed off" sounding. I think I've ruled out the Brobucker as the other two seem to be brighter and more aggressive sounding (the '78 definitely). I've checked into the new EVH frankenstein humbucker, but at 14.4K and A2 and a little more compressed than it's predecessor the '78, it seems pretty similar to a CC, so I've ruled it out too.
I've not played either (well, any, if we're including the Brobucker), and I've already done alot of reading here. Without saying what i'm already leaning towards, I thought I'd ask for a little more direction & opinions here.
Also, does the Custom Shop do relicing and is it included in the $160 price tag?
Your advice is most appreciated!
Last edited:
