Re: LOOKING FOR A NEW AMP, HELP!!!
Does the EVH5150 sound similar to the peavey 5150?
No. It is a completely different amp. I have the 6505 212 combo, which is basically a 5150 in combo form. Some differences between the head and combo like a little less gain in the combo, but close enough to compare the difference between it and the 5150 III.
I've been looking at getting a 5150 III for some time now and recently had a chance to sit down with a 50W and the 100W versions and A/B them. The Green channel is Fender clean, very nice. The Blue channel is the crunch channel. Plenty of gain on here. You can get Eddie's tone on this channel. Cleans up really nice with the guitar's volume control. Your blues and classic rock tones can be found here as well your hair metal. The Red channel is gain Heaven! Super saturated in the best way.
Differences with the 50W and the 100W that I saw was, as was pointed out, the shared EQ for the Green and Blue channel. So if you have the gain turned way down on the Green channel and turned up pretty high on the Blue channel, you get a pretty significant volume jump. If the gain on the Green channel is past noon the volume jump isn't as noticeable. This is not present with the 100W because of the 3 separate EQs. Along with 3 separate EQs you have 3 separate Presence controls for each channel on the 100W. The 50W has a Master Presence for all channels and a Master Resonance for all channels.
The Blue channel on the 50W has more gain than the 100W.
The 50W also has a headphone jack and a MIDI input. Actually some owners have solved the volume jump issue by using MIDI switching to change channels and bumping the volume up on the Green channel in their swathing path.
It's not a noisy amp either.
I preferred the tone of the 50W. I'm crossing my fingers and hoping at the NAMM show tomorrow they unveil a 50W with the volume jump issue solved!
Do yourself a favor and check out the 5150 III.