Need Floyd advice

Coma

Well-known member
The g-string saddle on my Floyd Rose comes loose when I do big bends. Doesn't happen with any of the other saddles. Don't want to risk over-tightening the saddle block. I need to troubleshoot it. Any advice on what to look for?
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

The string comes loose in the block\? or the saddle itself is sliding forward?

Either way, if it's coming loose then it just ain't tight enough yet.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

The saddle block is coming loose. The string remains locked firmly in place, but the saddle block slides forward. I'm a bit afraid of over-tightening and stripping the baseplate threads.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

The saddle-adjustment screw-head should round well before the screw's or saddle's threading would strip-out,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,IMO.
Over-tightening shouldn't be a problem if it's not even currently tight enough to hold the saddle in place,,,,,,,,,,,,,again just IMO.

Is it a made-in-germany OFR?
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

Sometimes the little block will split from over-tightening, and that could be the problem. Pull it out, and eyeball it.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

Yeah, locking blocks are fine, I went through them last year and replaced all the cracked ones.

Floys site lists those screws as unavailable. I actually wanted to order a set a while back, and no retailer carried them. That's weird as s**t to me.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

Will try to pull it all apart tomorrow and see if I can suss anything out. Hopefully, one of the more helpful local shops might be willing to help me with parts. I've had some good experiences dealing with Schaller directly before, but that was for something bigger than just a few screws. Will report back once results are in.

EDIT: Had a small window while waiting for computer to do some rendering work. Decided to open the Floyd up. First off, it's not an OFR, turns out I had gotten two bridges mixed up. Must've been more tired than I realised last night. It's an 80's Floyd, but a Schaller built (witht he thick base plate) and Jackson branded unit. As I was fiddling with it, another saddle popped loose. So I fully removed them both, and lo and behold, the finish underneath them wasn't flush. The edges around the screw hole had risen a bit. Overall the blaack coiting seems very sturdy, so could possibly be screws not being tightened enough and then tugging on upper layers of threads, causing them to bend outwards? Just a shot in the dark.

Used a tiny diamond file bring them back down to level with the base plate. Will slap on new strings when I have a chance and see if they stay put from here on out.
 
Last edited:
Re: Need Floyd advice

Sounds like a good start to the troubleshooting.

I'm just gunna mention here for anyone else that over-tightening anything on these is a bad idea.

Also, if you have a good fasteners store around you can usually get things like the 'saddle mounting screws' in a box of 100 for the price of what anyone sells two sets of them for.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

Will try to pull it all apart tomorrow and see if I can suss anything out. Hopefully, one of the more helpful local shops might be willing to help me with parts. I've had some good experiences dealing with Schaller directly before, but that was for something bigger than just a few screws. Will report back once results are in.

EDIT: Had a small window while waiting for computer to do some rendering work. Decided to open the Floyd up. First off, it's not an OFR, turns out I had gotten two bridges mixed up. Must've been more tired than I realised last night. It's an 80's Floyd, but a Schaller built (witht he thick base plate) and Jackson branded unit. As I was fiddling with it, another saddle popped loose. So I fully removed them both, and lo and behold, the finish underneath them wasn't flush. The edges around the screw hole had risen a bit. Overall the blaack coiting seems very sturdy, so could possibly be screws not being tightened enough and then tugging on upper layers of threads, causing them to bend outwards? Just a shot in the dark.

Used a tiny diamond file bring them back down to level with the base plate. Will slap on new strings when I have a chance and see if they stay put from here on out.

Didn't Ascension recently bashed these thick plate Schallers to be complete junk?

Apparently they're made from some too soft metal to hold together.

I'm not sure if it's worth it fixing, if that's correct.

EDIT: Here is that thread I recalled: https://forum.seymourduncan.com/showthread.php?325566-Floyd-rose-special-for-shaller&highlight=floyd
 
Last edited:
Re: Need Floyd advice

Didn't Ascension recently bashed these thick plate Schallers to be complete junk?

Apparently they're made from some too soft metal to hold together.

I'm not sure if it's worth it fixing, if that's correct.

EDIT: Here is that thread I recalled: https://forum.seymourduncan.com/showthread.php?325566-Floyd-rose-special-for-shaller&highlight=floyd

He did, and I respectfully disagree. Guitar was built in 1989 and that's still the original tremolo on there. I would not consider anything that holds up fine for 29 years to be rubbish. I have had other issues with it but I'm willing to chalk that up to a combination of design flaws inherent in the system as well as said old age. With that in mind, if the thing ever truly wears out, I'll just have to suck it up and get a new Floyd.



Also, if you have a good fasteners store around you can usually get things like the 'saddle mounting screws' in a box of 100 for the price of what anyone sells two sets of them for.

Agreed. Its well worth putting some time into searching.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

EDIT: Had a small window while waiting for computer to do some rendering work. Decided to open the Floyd up. First off, it's not an OFR, turns out I had gotten two bridges mixed up. Must've been more tired than I realised last night. It's an 80's Floyd, but a Schaller built (witht he thick base plate) and Jackson branded unit. As I was fiddling with it, another saddle popped loose./QUOTE]
Was about to ask it it was one of those units. The base plate screw holes strip VERY ease in those as that plate is NOT regular steel like real regular Shaller built Floyd is. Have had absolute fits with hose things on Gibson,Jackson, Hamer, Carvin and Washrburn guitars from the 80- 90 HATE that system!! I have replaced a couple with Ghoto Floyds because I could not get the saddle screws tight enough to stop the saddles from sliding and not strip. if you get it successfully intonated then locked plan to LEAVE IT ALONE as no joke IMO those systems are flat JUNK!!
Good luck man I have 2 guitars with that system right now and both I got locked down but have had a number of them that jus would not.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

Didn't Ascension recently bashed these thick plate Schallers to be complete junk?

Apparently they're made from some too soft metal to hold together.

I'm not sure if it's worth it fixing, if that's correct.

EDIT: Here is that thread I recalled: https://forum.seymourduncan.com/showthread.php?325566-Floyd-rose-special-for-shaller&highlight=floyd
Yep had fits with several over the years with those systems and own 2 now. Base plate is not real steel and is very soft so strips easily. The 2 guitars i own now ( my 92 Washburn MG 104 and Pinky my 1990 Carvin X220C) both locked down without a issue and are stable. However have had many with that system that would lock down and NOT hold before the screw holes stripped! If you strip the base plate hole it will have to have a new plate.The high end Ghoto Floyds will fit so if yours wont cooperate let me know i will show you which system will work. Good luck.
 
Re: Need Floyd advice

Throw it in the trash and replace it with a non-locking Fender bridge.

j/k :)

I had several Jackson guitars in the past with Jackson-branded bridges, and a Fender HM Strat with a Kahler Spyder. They were all pretty crappy compared to a Floyd.
 
Back
Top