Re: Need some pickup advice?
Welcome to the board DBT,
I can't fully answer your question because I've never tried actives. However, the metal pickups I've used that have worked well are the Distortion, the JB and the Custom. The Custom seems to have a great all-around sound with a vintage vibe and heavy delivery. I think the Custom has the best lead tone of the bunch. The JB is 80's all the way with great harmonics, but can sometimes be mushy on the bottom end in certain setups. The JB is probably the "funnest" of the three because it has a nice voice and you can just feel the hairspray in your hair when you play it. The Distortion is the latest I've tried and is in a temperamental instrument. It has alot of power and crunch, and I think some people feel it is a little over-the-top. It's a great metal pup, however, and I'm still deciding how much I like it.
As for comparison to actives, I'll let someone else chime in, and give you a bump up to the top of the list.
-Matt