Re: New tubes for Hot Rod Deluxe
Why do you "need" to replace your tubes? Has one or more gone bad, or are you looking for a different sound and/or gain from the amp?
+1 on Eurotubes being a one-trick pony. JJ tubes are just the ticket for a lot of amps/players, but it's worth experimenting IMHO. Just buy one of each 12AX7 and swap 'em in and out of V1 - that's where you'll hear the most difference.
Matched pairs of output tubes make perfect sense IMHO, but the "Full Re-Tube" kit concept is simply brilliant marketing. Seriously, buy a few 12AX7s and try to hear any difference between tubes in the later preamp stages. It depends on the amp (and your ears), but you just don't need to replace the full tube complement wholesale. Buy a variety of 2, 3 or 4 12AX7s and experiment. That way you'll find your sound.
Out of current production 12AX7 tubes, JJ, Tung Sol, Shuguang (9th generation Chinese), and Electro Harmonix are all worth checking out.
BTW the "balanced" 12AX7 for the phase inverter spot may also be more marketing than reality. No phase inverter circuit is perfectly matched before you even consider the tube(s). However, if one triode has a mu of 96 and the other triode puts out 105, that could be a problem. There doesn't seem to be a "right" answer on this subject.
I don't have much experience with different types of output tubes, but it's my understanding that JJ 6V6s are built in a slightly different way than vintage allowing them to handle higher voltages. They're also supposed to sound closer to a 6L6 than a true 6V6 does. All of that might be great for you and your amp...
I've had good experiences with Doug's Tubes, but there are other outfits that really know guitar amps and sell a variety of brands too.
Hope this helps,
Chip