NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

DreX

New member
Antiquity II Surfers are my favorite Strat pickups, they sound full and powerful, especially at high volumes. They're slightly hotter, and slightly darker than typical Strat pickups, and are resistant to sounding harsh or brittle like most typical Strat pickups. Sometimes, but not often, they are a little too dark for what I want to do, so I'll turn to lower wound pickups, like Fender CS 69's or the "Fender 60th Anniversary Strat Pickup Set" for something brighter, but I wanted to see what would Ant II Surfers would sound like if they were simply underwound a bit, so I put in an order with the custom shop for 10% underwinds.

Where as the Ant II's have a heavy, dark, piano-like clang and sustain and moderate compression, the underwound Ant II's are very, very bright and light bodied, a sweet high end and a delicate attack. They're biased towards the low end of a wide dynamic range, which is to say that standard picking strength results in a rather quiet, light-picking sort of sound, but striking the strings with force gets very loud. If the stock Ant II's are leather, these under wounds are definitely lace.

The bridge vintage Strat pickup is often criticized for being thin and piercing, and unfortunately, that's doubly the case with the underwound bridge. A typical Ant II hot bridge is wound to 9.9k with 43 AWG, this one is wound to 8.6k. It is difficult to hit the strings on the bridge pickup and not get a rather shrill sound, reminiscent of a bridge humbucker wired out of phase with itself. If I pick over the 20th fret, it's not so bad, and if I dial down the tone knob knob with a .003uF cap, it sounds pretty decent, and a stock Strat isn't going to allow for that, but a treble roll off could be hardwired with a trim pot.

On the plus, the B+M position is very present, very quacky, and very alive with harmonic detail, the kind of thing that stacked noiseless don't know they're missing. The strong suit of these pickups is definately the 2 and 4 positions.

The middle pickup has a ton of quack all by itself, and is very present. The middle pickup often bores Strat players, but the responsiveness as well as the bright presence really makes the middle position a lot more interesting than would be expected.

The neck pickup on a Strat is usually pretty solid and full sounding, even with low wound vintage Strat pickups, if only because there's so much kinetic energy in that location. I've never heard a dainty neck pickup - until now. That's not necessarily a bad thing, it's still very expressive and widely dynamic, but not as ballsy as any other neck pickup I've tried. As with the bridge, applying tone control with a .003 uF cap mellows it out and makes for a very pretty neck sound with lots of harmonic activity making it's way out of the amp.

Overall they are somewhat comparable to Fender CS 69's, but these feature weaker A5 magnets than the CS 69's, so the attack is bit softer, less bass and mids and more high end presence. The Fender 60th Anniversary set with A3's is somewhere between the underwound Ant II and the CS 69's. Both are overall more aggressive than the Ant II underwounds.

The DCR values for the underwinds ended up being: B 8.5k , M 6.0k, N 5.8k

If anyone else were interested in ordering such a set from the custom shop, I'd say maybe don't go quite so underwound, and/or put a push/pull tone knob that allows for a .003 uF cap alternative to the usual .022 / .047, because these pickups sound utterly beautiful rolled at 50% with the .003 uF, sounding rich and lush without being too bright.

Here are sound clips comparing the Ant II to the underwound Ant II:

Seymour Duncan Antiquity II Surfer Underwound (neck & middle DCR high 5's, gauss 40)


Seymour Duncan Antiquity II Surfers (neck & middle DCR low 6's, gauss 40)


Antiquity Neck Pickup Comparison

v1VJwTt.jpg


Pics

8bq7fjh.jpg


wVQvYUL.jpg
 
Last edited:
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

So it would appear that underwound is not a good choice for the bridge, but otherwise quite useful in the neck and middle.
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

Cool review, I've always wondered what a slightly underwound set of Antiquity IIs would sound like.
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

So it would appear that underwound is not a good choice for the bridge, but otherwise quite useful in the neck and middle.

I think it depends on the music you are playing, what amp you are running through and your settings. I've had 6-8K bridge pickups in Strats that sounded great, could do twang/surf/rockabilly/chicken-picken and by just rolling a little treble off and increasing amp input gain sounded near enough to their overwound counterparts.
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

I've been known to be quite particular about pickups in Strats- Its my opinion that a pickup is not a one size fits all option.

One guitar I got without the original pickups (I tend pretty much lean this way, unless theres RWRP in the middle), I must have had at least a dozen combinations in there. EMG's, Bill Lawrences, Surfers, a Texas Hot [neck] in the bridge (which was great in this case), Lollars, 2 different Suhr sets... Settled on a Suhr V54 set for that guitar.
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

DreX, do you have any clips of yourself playing this guitar?
We'd get a better sense of what you're talking about by listening.

Martin Mull said:
Writing about music is like dancing about architecture.
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

^^ DreX noted in another thread recently that he doesn't record anything so there is no way to corroborate any of his opinions or observations about tone.

coincedentally, blueman is in the same situation. :\
 
Last edited:
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

Antiquity II Surfers are my favorite Strat pickups, they sound full and powerful, especially at high volumes. They're slightly hotter, and slightly darker than typical Strat pickups, and are resistant to sounding harsh or brittle like most typical Strat pickups. Sometimes, but not often, they are a little too dark for what I want to do, so I'll turn to lower wound pickups, like Fender CS 69's or the "Fender 60th Anniversary Strat Pickup Set" for something brighter, but I wanted to see what would Ant II Surfers would sound like if they were simply underwound a bit, so I put in an order with the custom shop for 10% underwinds.

Where as the Ant II's have a heavy, dark, piano-like clang and sustain and moderate compression, the underwound Ant II's are very, very bright and light bodied, a sweet high end and a delicate attack. They're biased towards the low end of a wide dynamic range, which is to say that standard picking strength results in a rather quiet, light-picking sort of sound, but striking the strings with force gets very loud. If the stock Ant II's are leather, these under wounds are definitely lace.

The bridge vintage Strat pickup is often criticized for being thin and piercing, and unfortunately, that's doubly the case with the underwound bridge. A typical Ant II hot bridge is wound to 9.9k with 43 AWG, this one is wound to 8.6k. It is difficult to hit the strings on the bridge pickup and not get a rather shrill sound, reminiscent of a bridge humbucker wired out of phase with itself. If I pick over the 20th fret, it's not so bad, and if I dial down the tone knob knob with a .003uF cap, it sounds pretty decent, and a stock Strat isn't going to allow for that, but a treble roll off could be hardwired with a trim pot.

On the plus, the B+M position is very present, very quacky, and very alive with harmonic detail, the kind of thing that stacked noiseless don't know they're missing. The strong suit of these pickups is definately the 2 and 4 positions.

The middle pickup has a ton of quack all by itself, and is very present. The middle pickup often bores Strat players, but the responsiveness as well as the bright presence really makes the middle position a lot more interesting than would be expected.

The neck pickup on a Strat is usually pretty solid and full sounding, even with low wound vintage Strat pickups, if only because there's so much kinetic energy in that location. I've never heard a dainty neck pickup - until now. That's not necessarily a bad thing, it's still very expressive and widely dynamic, but not as ballsy as any other neck pickup I've tried. As with the bridge, applying tone control with a .003 uF cap mellows it out and makes for a very pretty neck sound with lots of harmonic activity making it's way out of the amp.

Overall they are somewhat comparable to Fender CS 69's, but these feature weaker A5 magnets than the CS 69's, so the attack is bit softer, less bass and mids and more high end presence. The Fender 60th Anniversary set with A3's is somewhere between the underwound Ant II and the CS 69's. Both are overall more aggressive than the Ant II underwounds.

The DCR values for the underwinds ended up being: B 8.5k , M 6.0k, N 5.8k

If anyone else were interested in ordering such a set from the custom shop, I'd say maybe don't go quite so underwound, and/or put a push/pull tone knob that allows for a .003 uF cap alternative to the usual .022 / .047, because these pickups sound utterly beautiful rolled at 50% with the .003 uF, sounding rich and lush without being too bright.



Antiquity Neck Pickup Comparison

v1VJwTt.jpg


Pics

8bq7fjh.jpg


wVQvYUL.jpg
Stellar analysis. You even included a graph!

I like graphs. Especially when there are colorful lines.


:bigok:, Old Kinderhook!
 
Last edited:
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

They didn't sound that appealing until they were compared to the 69s. Interested in the clips. :)
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

DreX, do you have any clips of yourself playing this guitar?
We'd get a better sense of what you're talking about by listening.

They didn't sound that appealing until they were compared to the 69s. Interested in the clips. :)

OK, here's sound clips. Recording audio with Windows really sucks. Each demo starts at the bridge pickup and moves towards the neck:

Seymour Duncan Antiquity II Surfer Underwound (neck & middle DCR high 5's, gauss 40)


Seymour Duncan Antiquity II Surfers (neck & middle DCR low 6's, gauss 40)


Seymour Duncan Antiquity I Texas Hot (neck & middle DCR low 6's, gauss 30)


Fender Custom Shop 69 (DCR low 5's, gauss 40)


60th Anniversary 1954 Stratocaster Pickup Set (DCR high 5's, magnet gauss 25)
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

Antiquity II Surfers are my favorite Strat pickups, they sound full and powerful, especially at high volumes. They're slightly hotter, and slightly darker than typical Strat pickups, and are resistant to sounding harsh or brittle like most typical Strat pickups. Sometimes, but not often, they are a little too dark for what I want to do, so I'll turn to lower wound pickups, like Fender CS 69's or the "Fender 60th Anniversary Strat Pickup Set" for something brighter, but I wanted to see what would Ant II Surfers would sound like if they were simply underwound a bit, so I put in an order with the custom shop for 10% underwinds.

Where as the Ant II's have a heavy, dark, piano-like clang and sustain and moderate compression, the underwound Ant II's are very, very bright and light bodied, a sweet high end and a delicate attack. They're biased towards the low end of a wide dynamic range, which is to say that standard picking strength results in a rather quiet, light-picking sort of sound, but striking the strings with force gets very loud. If the stock Ant II's are leather, these under wounds are definitely lace.

The bridge vintage Strat pickup is often criticized for being thin and piercing, and unfortunately, that's doubly the case with the underwound bridge. A typical Ant II hot bridge is wound to 9.9k with 43 AWG, this one is wound to 8.6k. It is difficult to hit the strings on the bridge pickup and not get a rather shrill sound, reminiscent of a bridge humbucker wired out of phase with itself. If I pick over the 20th fret, it's not so bad, and if I dial down the tone knob knob with a .003uF cap, it sounds pretty decent, and a stock Strat isn't going to allow for that, but a treble roll off could be hardwired with a trim pot.

On the plus, the B+M position is very present, very quacky, and very alive with harmonic detail, the kind of thing that stacked noiseless don't know they're missing. The strong suit of these pickups is definately the 2 and 4 positions.

The middle pickup has a ton of quack all by itself, and is very present. The middle pickup often bores Strat players, but the responsiveness as well as the bright presence really makes the middle position a lot more interesting than would be expected.

The neck pickup on a Strat is usually pretty solid and full sounding, even with low wound vintage Strat pickups, if only because there's so much kinetic energy in that location. I've never heard a dainty neck pickup - until now. That's not necessarily a bad thing, it's still very expressive and widely dynamic, but not as ballsy as any other neck pickup I've tried. As with the bridge, applying tone control with a .003 uF cap mellows it out and makes for a very pretty neck sound with lots of harmonic activity making it's way out of the amp.

Overall they are somewhat comparable to Fender CS 69's, but these feature weaker A5 magnets than the CS 69's, so the attack is bit softer, less bass and mids and more high end presence. The Fender 60th Anniversary set with A3's is somewhere between the underwound Ant II and the CS 69's. Both are overall more aggressive than the Ant II underwounds.

The DCR values for the underwinds ended up being: B 8.5k , M 6.0k, N 5.8k

If anyone else were interested in ordering such a set from the custom shop, I'd say maybe don't go quite so underwound, and/or put a push/pull tone knob that allows for a .003 uF cap alternative to the usual .022 / .047, because these pickups sound utterly beautiful rolled at 50% with the .003 uF, sounding rich and lush without being too bright.

Here are sound clips comparing the Ant II to the underwound Ant II:

Seymour Duncan Antiquity II Surfer Underwound (neck & middle DCR high 5's, gauss 40)


Seymour Duncan Antiquity II Surfers (neck & middle DCR low 6's, gauss 40)


Antiquity Neck Pickup Comparison

v1VJwTt.jpg


Pics

8bq7fjh.jpg


wVQvYUL.jpg

Dre this is awesome! What an informative thread and the clips sound great. Did my interest in looking into a custom underwound surfer set make you want to try a set, or did you want them even before I asked about the idea? Either way glad you pulled the trigger. Wanted to myself just haven't had the money unfortunately. Enjoy them man! I like the way they are a little less dark and have some extra sparkle. For the record I think the neck in particular benefits a great deal at 5.8
 
Last edited:
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

Dre this is awesome! What an informative thread and the clips sound great. Did my interest in looking into a custom underwound surfer set make you want to try a set, or did you want them even before I asked about the idea? Either way glad you pulled the trigger. Wanted to myself just haven't had the money unfortunately. Enjoy them man! I like the way they are a little less dark and have some extra sparkle. For the record I think the neck in particular benefits a great deal at 5.8

I had vaguely pondered it before, because the stock pickups are wound to 6.3 with weaker A5's and sound a bit dark (to good effect), but I'm a big fan of Fender CS 69's and the 60th Anniversary set, so I was wondered what a true vintage output Antiquity might sound like. When I saw your post asking about the same thing, I figured that elevated it from good experiment to great experiment.

Overall the outcome is not something in between the three, though, the under winds are brighter, sweeter and more delicate than the Fenders. I'm not a big fan of sound demos because, IMO, when you listen to them, you might get the impression they all sound about the same, but when you actually play them, it feels different. I had to hit the strings a little harder and finesse then differently with the underwinds, but you can't tell that from a recording.

I should write a follow up review in abut a month after the honey moon period is over. I jammed with them Friday. The drummer loved the sound. They are uber Stratty.

Another thing I try some day would be an underwound Texas Hot (contradiction in terms not withstanding), because to my ears the stock Texas Hots are a bit too dark (and that does come through in the sound sample a few posts up) and an underwind would surely brighten them up a bit.

If you ever thing of ordering underwound Ant IIs, you can save some money and just get underwound neck and middle pickups, and then buy a stock neck Ant II and use that as the bridge pickup.
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

Interesting. They sound better than the 69s in the clips. Now I want to try them....

thanks DreX. :)
 
Re: NPD: Custom Ant II. Surfers Under-Wound Review

Interesting. They sound better than the 69s in the clips. Now I want to try them....

thanks DreX. :)

Good to hear, just to reiterate, I think you can just order an under-wound neck and middle, then buy a stock neck and call it the bridge, and save $30+. The underwound bridge is the weak spot of the set I received, IMO, it's a 43 AWG underwound "hot" bridge.
 
Back
Top