Opinions on metal tone

Re: Opinions on metal tone

It sounds like a Mark IV alone.With a decent bass and drums, it will be really cool! If used alone (like for the riff-offs) it would need more substance.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Thanks for your thoughts!

I agree, but how do you define substance? I was thinking that this lacked bass (my first try had waay too much bass, blaming my headphones).. I guess I was looking for a sound to fit with bass and drums..
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

you need to backen up the gain on that distortion sound just a tad. Since it's double tracked, it's kind of muddy. i'm sure it's *****in' by itself, and would work live, but for recording you have to clean it up a bit. I like that riff. If you're in a band, I suggest you try to write the rest of it WITH the band. When writting metal, I found that alot of what I was writting was just showcasing MY talents, and a band like Metallica or Slayer are really about the impact of the full band, not just the riffs.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

you need to backen up the gain on that distortion sound just a tad. Since it's double tracked, it's kind of muddy.

Man, you are right! Haha, I was originally just thinking to make one track of this, but as I had laid down the first, I thought why not try two tracks? And forgot all about the gain. Thanks!


i'm sure it's *****in' by itself, and would work live, but for recording you have to clean it up a bit. I like that riff. If you're in a band, I suggest you try to write the rest of it WITH the band. When writting metal, I found that alot of what I was writting was just showcasing MY talents, and a band like Metallica or Slayer are really about the impact of the full band, not just the riffs.

Good points all around. Not in a band though, just wanted to do something I rarely do. I do have a bass and EZD, so I might try my hand at making complete metal songs later if I want to.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

I am by no means an expert (or even close to one), but I think if you backed off the gain just a little and tightened up the double tracking then it would sound killer.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

It's got a super dry feeling to it, kind of an upper midrange scratchiness. Personally not at all my taste, but it could be what you're going for. FWIW I don't think it would sit in a mix very well, would be kind of 'on top' of everything. I think you'd be better off using a different model (AxeFX, right?) like the Uber/Recto/5150 or a blend of them, and grab some of the Redwirez impulses.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

I am by no means an expert (or even close to one), but I think if you backed off the gain just a little and tightened up the double tracking then it would sound killer.

Agreed.

It's got a super dry feeling to it, kind of an upper midrange scratchiness. Personally not at all my taste, but it could be what you're going for. FWIW I don't think it would sit in a mix very well, would be kind of 'on top' of everything. I think you'd be better off using a different model (AxeFX, right?) like the Uber/Recto/5150 or a blend of them, and grab some of the Redwirez impulses.

I have been reluctant to using reverb, so there's none of that. I know next to nothing about making metal sounds that work, but intuitively thought I should avoid blending in some wet stuff in it. Although Devin could easily prove me wrong on that..

I can see that it could be "on top". I did use the Recto (Orange), though. The most difficult part is dialing in the bass - do you have any general pointers, tips and tricks to that one?

I've been hearing good words on those IRs, do you have any models to recommend?
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

I have been reluctant to using reverb, so there's none of that. I know next to nothing about making metal sounds that work, but intuitively thought I should avoid blending in some wet stuff in it. Although Devin could easily prove me wrong on that..

I can see that it could be "on top". I did use the Recto (Orange), though. The most difficult part is dialing in the bass - do you have any general pointers, tips and tricks to that one?

I've been hearing good words on those IRs, do you have any models to recommend?

By 'dry' I mean 'undersaturated.' Dry = VHT, wet = 5150 kind of thing.

If you listen to most of Devin's better productions, actually, you'll find that the rhythm guitars are oddly un-verbed/delayed like he'd usually do.

Don't remember a whole ton about the AxeFX's specific controls, I just know the poweramp sag setting was KEY in getting anything usable out of it.

Definitely get the Recto 4x12 impulses, probably the best 10 bucks (is that how much an individual cab is?) you'll ever spend on that AxeFX rig of yours!
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Gottcha on all points, thanks a bunch! (yeah, the cabs go for around that price)
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

sounds like a chainsaw, I like it.

dang, peeps have to drop even more cash for cabs with that thang? do you have to put a quarter in to start it up too, hehe
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

I think it's missing something in the mids. Maybe back off the gain a tad, and experiment with adding some body. Sounds just a bit flat, to me. JMHO, of course!

Good work, though!:beerchug:
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Sh!t, I love it.

First thing to my mind was that it would sit PERFECTLY in a mix with bass and drums.

Which shows me your maturity as a player --- not trying to do it all with the six string.

I love it. Don't touch it.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

I agree with Jeff/VK, it's too dry sounding. Do bear in mind both him and I are Andy Sneap forumites, so that explains our taste in saturated guitar tones :laugh2:

Seriously though, don't be afraid to up the gain. As much as people often say "TURN DOWN THE GAIN DANG NABBIT!" sometimes just turning it up is really the way to go.
Of course I don't mean crank the gain to 11, but if crank it enough that the palm mutes reach their full intensity and chunk, then you have enough gain and don't need anymore.
It's quite a lot of gain, but that shouldn't be the max gain on the 5150/Dual Recto type models by any stretch of the imagination.
Some more saturation and slightly lower mid sag is never a bad thing.
You do perhaps trade a tiny bit of clarity with that approach (at least if you're wanting to play full, big 6 string chords anyway), but it just sounds better for metal really
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Dry is good - especially for rhythm tracks - keep them bone dry like you have it The sound you have right now will work awesome with bass and drums. Tone is the most subjective thing in the world but what's important to remember is that you keep within your sonic realm (i.e. stay out of the bass space and the cymbal space) That way, when you start adding everything else together it will work and sound good. I hear plenty of guitar tones out there that sound great by themselves but slam them together with other instruments and they all barf on each other. Best way to fester out a guitar tone is get it with the other instruments and tweak to get it in the best spot sonically.There's no right or wrong - just need to listen to your ears - not your brain.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Dry is good - especially for rhythm tracks - keep them bone dry like you have it The sound you have right now will work awesome with bass and drums. Tone is the most subjective thing in the world but what's important to remember is that you keep within your sonic realm (i.e. stay out of the bass space and the cymbal space) That way, when you start adding everything else together it will work and sound good. I hear plenty of guitar tones out there that sound great by themselves but slam them together with other instruments and they all barf on each other. Best way to fester out a guitar tone is get it with the other instruments and tweak to get it in the best spot sonically.There's no right or wrong - just need to listen to your ears - not your brain.

You say this almost as if a saturated, somewhat saggy in the lower mids tone can't work in the mix......which is just far from the truth..
The fact is his tone is just too dry for modern metal, and it doesn't matter if he puts a full mix around it, it will still be clear that the tone is too dry and have an unpleasant character in the upper mids
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Based on the responses (which are divided!), I think I will try turning up the sag, and not doing so much about the gain level other than turning it slightly up as well, as I will double track this.

sounds like a chainsaw, I like it.

dang, peeps have to drop even more cash for cabs with that thang? do you have to put a quarter in to start it up too, hehe

It's seriously the best investment I've done in a long time. I love the thing. :)

I think it's missing something in the mids. Maybe back off the gain a tad, and experiment with adding some body. Sounds just a bit flat, to me. JMHO, of course!

Good work, though!:beerchug:

Gots plenty of mids in it though. But I do have a lot of treble, add to that the bright switch. The presence is also a tad too much. But I have also turned down the treble with an EQ from 8K or something. Not sure about the gain bit though. I was initially thinking the same as you, that it had a little too much gain, but VK and PM want more saturation. Not sure if the sag can do that alone, but I'll experiment.

Sh!t, I love it.

First thing to my mind was that it would sit PERFECTLY in a mix with bass and drums.

Which shows me your maturity as a player --- not trying to do it all with the six string.

I love it. Don't touch it.

Now here's where I get unsure. :laugh2: You're really in favor of the tone, especially with a band setting (which was what I intended to use the tone for). I might eventually try this clip with bass and drums when I get more time on my hands.

Thanks for the compliments by the way!

I agree with Jeff/VK, it's too dry sounding. Do bear in mind both him and I are Andy Sneap forumites, so that explains our taste in saturated guitar tones :laugh2:

Seriously though, don't be afraid to up the gain. As much as people often say "TURN DOWN THE GAIN DANG NABBIT!" sometimes just turning it up is really the way to go.
Of course I don't mean crank the gain to 11, but if crank it enough that the palm mutes reach their full intensity and chunk, then you have enough gain and don't need anymore.
It's quite a lot of gain, but that shouldn't be the max gain on the 5150/Dual Recto type models by any stretch of the imagination.
Some more saturation and slightly lower mid sag is never a bad thing.
You do perhaps trade a tiny bit of clarity with that approach (at least if you're wanting to play full, big 6 string chords anyway), but it just sounds better for metal really

An entirely new landscape for me this, dude. I will get back after some more experimentation. :)

Dry is good - especially for rhythm tracks - keep them bone dry like you have it The sound you have right now will work awesome with bass and drums. Tone is the most subjective thing in the world but what's important to remember is that you keep within your sonic realm (i.e. stay out of the bass space and the cymbal space) That way, when you start adding everything else together it will work and sound good. I hear plenty of guitar tones out there that sound great by themselves but slam them together with other instruments and they all barf on each other. Best way to fester out a guitar tone is get it with the other instruments and tweak to get it in the best spot sonically.There's no right or wrong - just need to listen to your ears - not your brain.

You and I6 agree. Makes me unsure! :)

When summer comes, I will try to make a full band mix with this clip and sound, and a new clip with an adjusted sound with a more saturated tone. Could be interesting.

it will still be clear that the tone is too dry and have an unpleasant character in the upper mids

Might be attributed to high treble, bright switch and presence levels.. I'll adjust those parameters!
 
Last edited:
Re: Opinions on metal tone

You say this almost as if a saturated, somewhat saggy in the lower mids tone can't work in the mix......which is just far from the truth..
The fact is his tone is just too dry for modern metal, and it doesn't matter if he puts a full mix around it, it will still be clear that the tone is too dry and have an unpleasant character in the upper mids

Nope - didn't say that. Dry is the absence of effects as VK clarified. There are numerous metal tones out there - whether it's "modern" or "old school" was not the question. I also stated that tone is completely subjective so there will always be someone who likes it and someone who doesn't. That doesn't mean it's good or bad just may not fit someone else's idea of what it "should" be. Critique is good for anyone trying to dial in a tone but when you don't define what exactly you are looking for and just put something out there, you just end up with somebody else's idea of what your tone should be.
 
Re: Opinions on metal tone

Personally I think it sounds alright, but needs more... shape (?) in the mids. They're very up-front and like VK said a little scratchy. Not necessarily bad of course but I'd like more flavour.

I don't think you need any more gain but after you tweak the EQ a bit more that could change. I also feel like VK/PM have the right idea... the former's always had great tones in his stuff so I trust his opinion. You've got the right idea about the Presence, Bright and Treble. Find the right combination without too much of any of them and the tone will get smoother.

You're on your way to a great metal tone in context though! Keep experimenting.
 
Back
Top