Re: Pickup recommendation for a les paul. HELP
I've used APH II's, 59's, Seths, C5's, CC's, PG's and JB's. Mainly in my Dean Hardtail, which is sonicly similar to a Les Paul. Currently I have a C5/Seth in my Les Paul due to lack of other choices.
I can dial in some really sweet sounds with the Seth, but the C5 just has too much bite for my taste. Lack of mids...it's just too focused for my taste. I didn't like the PG in the neck of my Hardtail either, it didn't have enough clarity for me.
The set that I keep going back to again and again is the APH set. That's what's in my Hardtail now, and that's what's going in my Les Paul. I'll go with a stock APH neck bucker, and will build a slight variation of Slash's APH Custom Shop Bridge model at users day. I really feel that for my taste (classic rock, blues) that the APH is the best pickup for letting the true tone of the instrument ring through. I know my Hardtail will sound different than my Les Paul, even though the pups will be similar.
To my ears, A2 magnets are just more musical and friendly. YMMV.