I haven't found a value for the volume that I can live with. 250K is too muffled and 500K is too bright and hard edged. Maybe a 333K pot would be a happy medium, but I haven't tried one yet?
I tried the resistor and pot combo. At 100% it sounds right, but the range of the pot didn't sound the same afterward. I was going to try a Gibson 300K pot, but I think the shaft size is the wrong size for a Tele control plate?I've never tried this, but you should be able to approximate all sort of values in between 250k and 500k with a variable resistor like this one by soldering one end to the pickup-side lug of a 500k volume pot, and the center lead to ground (it doesn't matter which), and what that would do is put two resistors worth of load in parallel, so if you have a 500k audio volume and you dial in 800k ohm resistance on the variable resistor, you'll have a combined parallel resistance of 307 k ohm when the volume is at 10, about the same same as a 300k pot. I'm not 100% sure what it would do to the sweep, but nothing too bad I don't think. This isn't taking into account the load of the tone pot, though. You might also just try switching to a smaller value tone pot to change the overall load, depending one what type of guitar this is.
I tried the resistor and pot combo. At 100% it sounds right, but the range of the pot didn't sound the same afterward. I was going to try a Gibson 300K pot, but I think the shaft size is the wrong size for a Tele control plate?
You are absolutely correct sir...I was thinking Tele because that's where I have my Quarter Pound pup. I've had Tele on the brain lately.
Anyone ever put their Quarter Pounds in covers?
GFS has some models with fatter pole pieces as well http://www.guitarfetish.com/Strat-and-Tele-Guitar-Pickups_c_8.html
I have a quarter pound in the bridge with a 250k and a .22 in my strat. I think it sounds great.