POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

ItsaBass said:
not sure if trolling, or just dead stupid...
Click to expand...

Surely no one could be that stupid. This guy is talking Fender Custom Shop and Zephyrs, yet thinks the material the knobs are made of might have an effect on tone? Really? I'm not buying it...
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Chris of Arabia said:
Surely no one could be that stupid. This guy is talking Fender Custom Shop and Zephyrs, yet thinks the material the knobs are made of might have an effect on tone? Really? I'm not buying it...
Click to expand...

Actually wondering why with all the money apparently put into looks along with sound why plastic remained a popular choice - although I think the explanation regarding the molding was a good one I still think the cost of a wooden set of controls (probably not much at all) could not have been the reason very few electric guitars have wooden knobs.

Do you guys know the best non-tremolo bridge for a rhythm player? Thanks again guys.....
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

i can't believe that no-one has advised that the wooden control knobs are great for clean and blues tones, due to their earthy, woody tone.
there is a magic, a smooth yet grainy-ness, to them that can only really be appreciated in person.

i also really love the aggressive tones i get out of my sharp pointy knobs on my metal guitar.
it really cuts through.
i bleed a lot, but it makes for a pleasing offering to the dark lords and their subordinates.

HTH,
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Metal knobs give a brighter yet heavier tone.


Slightly off topic, I have found that a kill switch works best with no switch tip.
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

While we're asking stupid questions, which has better tone, 1" strap pin screws or 1 1/8" strap pin screws?
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

The sadder part is I have a friend who is a big audiophile and he spent a nice chunk of cash for african cocobolo wood knobs for his stereo amp cause and i quote "The plastic knobs had too harsh of a sound" for him. As PT Barnum said theres one born every minute...
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Hmmmm... ok, I`ll bite...

Miget Kotla said:
I've seen some nice looking wooden knobs on great custom guitars and I'm wondering what you guys think the absolute best sounding pots are for volume/tone and the rest?
Click to expand...

POTS? CTS or Bourns, Alpha in a pinch.

After seeing some wooden switches/knobs I figured I'd give them a try unless someone said they actually affected the way the strat will sound in a negative way.
Is wood okay there?
Click to expand...
No, they just look different and cost 10-20x as much as plastic or knurled metal.

Any real difference?
Click to expand...
Yes, they look different and cost 10-20x as much as plastic or knurled metal.

I'm looking for the absolute best quality and sound - looks come second but man that wood stuff looks nice there!

Thanks!
Click to expand...

"Best" is subjective at best when it comes to sound, one persons Fat" is another`s "muddy", just as one person`S "bright" ia another`s "icepick". That said, the actual value and taper of the pots will have 100x more effect than the actual manufacturer, and the material the knobs are made of makes about as much tonal difference as the color of your socks.

As far as quality: cheap wooden knobs without threaded inserts generally love to split in 2 at the most inopportune moment, especuially when made of improperly dried exotic woods like most of the ones you can find on eBay.

If you really want them, your best bet is to go to a craftsman specialized in turning wood, I do not at this time know of ANY manufacturer that makes these to a level of quality I would accept on one of my own instruments. Expect a set of 4 knobs to start at about 50$ + materials.
 
Last edited:
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

DrNewcenstein said:
While we're asking stupid questions, which has better tone, 1" strap pin screws or 1 1/8" strap pin screws?
Click to expand...

My buddies Epi has both and it kills, but he needs to change his strap. I'll tell him about the wooden knobs.:bs2:
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

If I were you I'd hold off on the CS guitar and 1000 dollar pups and take some time to learn how a guitar works first. It doesn't matter how much things cost if you don't understand how to make those pieces work together you probably will be disappointed in the end. I kinda really hope your not being serious.
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Im taking a trip downt to middle earth this weekend to get some unicorn hairs. Im going to make my own set of unicorn hair wound humbuckers and make picks from their horns. Frodo and Harry Potter are coming with me. Should be fun
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

My buddy named Skwisgaar has a guitar made out of Christ's cross. Ultimate tone wood. Period. His knobs are also made out of chunks from the stone that covered the entrance to his tomb, and pots made out of the metal from the holy grail. Has never ending sustain, absolute clarity, no hum, rock solid tuning stability, perfect intonation, thickest and most powerful tone I've ever heard, and it sounds great clean and distorted. The only thing that could make it better if the strings were made from the hair of Jesus, as they improve tone.

Also, the best bridges for rhythm playing are the Japanese Jazzmaster bridges.
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Well, I tried every knob under the sun: metal (copper sounds especially 'carrot-y'), wooden, plastic, glass, aluminum, the wonderfully transparent tone of no knob at all. I'm sorry to report that only the following does Zephyrs justice:

http://gizmodo.com/031918/the-500-wooden-knob

Unfortunately it seems to be out of production, so expect to spend a fortune on a vintage NOS one, if you're lucky enough to find it.

PS: The secret to Dimebag's tone? "Dimebag traction knobs". Google it up ;)
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Christopher Caruana said:
Im taking a trip downt to middle earth this weekend to get some unicorn hairs. Im going to make my own set of unicorn hair wound humbuckers and make picks from their horns. Frodo and Harry Potter are coming with me. Should be fun
Click to expand...

if you get close enough, grab me some wax off its junk.
best nut lube there is.
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

Amplifuzz said:
Well, I tried every knob under the sun: metal (copper sounds especially 'carrot-y'), wooden, plastic, glass, aluminum, the wonderfully transparent tone of no knob at all. I'm sorry to report that only the following does Zephyrs justice:

http://gizmodo.com/031918/the-500-wooden-knob

Unfortunately it seems to be out of production, so expect to spend a fortune on a vintage NOS one, if you're lucky enough to find it.

PS: The secret to Dimebag's tone? "Dimebag traction knobs". Google it up ;)
Click to expand...

You are so right about those traction knobs. My Dean Razor back doesn't even have a Floyd and I was pulling off dive bombs like no bodies business.
 
Re: POTS>>> IS WOOD THE BEST???

computer-close-hulk.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

P
Nazgul Sentient install help - Possible wiring discrepancy from the factory?
Replies
1
Views
252
Mincer
Mincer
L
Trying to be different
Replies
9
Views
151
Artie
Artie
Butch Snyder
Hats off to the Hades Gates!!!
Replies
4
Views
770
Masta' C
Masta' C
P
Is there an alternative to the 4PDT 25K push pull pot?
Replies
0
Views
289
psychepool
P
Flashdogger
Frustrated with this wiring?
Replies
18
Views
931
Flashdogger
Flashdogger
Back
Top