Re: Power tube deterioration
To be honest with you...it is pointless to come up with some scheme to judge tubes.
Power Tubes (assuming they are functioning properly) tend to "wear out" slowly...loose punch, definition, and low end. But who cares.? You should always have spares. So you swap in a new set and see if there is a big change.
No need to sit there and try to listen for more mids, more responsiveness, etc etc. If the improvement is obvious, then the "old" tubes were due for replacement. If not, put the old tubes back in and keep playing them.
Same with noise and microphonics. No need to ask...Just change the tubes and see what you hear and feel.
Keep in mind that tubes Can and Do go bad at any time...always have spares.
best