I agree totally GuitarDoc.
I’ve had similar experience with the enclosed type. But, using them is necessary in some circumstances, i.e. a thin body.
Further consideration, every time I have used one, it was noisy and soon intermittent. In one instance I was forced to use a 2P3T on,on,on toggle switch luckily it was pickguard mounted. I was able to redrill the slot and cover it with a camouflage sticker.
}!€