RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

JeffB

Let it B
these absolutely $hitty DR brand strings again...

(bear with me, I'm torqued up here :laugh2: )

I have NEVER EVER EVARRRRRRRRR had such a piss-poor experience with a guitar related product. I've have bought 12 sets of these things ( Pure Blues, and Tite-Fits) in the past year and a half or so. I've bought them from various retailers both local and online.

In the past my experience has been either these are the best strings I've ever put on an axe, or the biggest frigging HEADACHE I've experienced.

My issues are thus

1) Extreme wear within a couple of days on the wound strings (flatten out/groove and/or windings break. Whether they are pure nickel or nickel coated)

2) Rusted plain strings, straight out of the (vaccum sealed) box

3) quick breakage at the saddles (but not having breakage with other brands on the same guitar)

The biggest issue? (if those were not enough)

4) Extreme out of tune/intonation problems.

Right after I got my new Dean, I scrapped the strings that were on it cos they were a lil' old and dead. The shop did not have D'addarios in stock in the guages I wanted, and I'm always experimenting so I grabbed some EB Slinkys and some DR Tite-Fits.(see below why I even bothered). 10-46.

I put on a set of Ernie Ball Slinky 10s, tweaked the rod and action and the guitar really came to life. But they were a little too sloppy on the low strings. I knew from past experience that the Tite-Fits were tight on the low strings and yet still very flexible for bending on the upper strings.

Well I put them on, tweaked the rod & action, and the guitar sounded absolutely brilliant. Increased resonance and sustain, clear as a bell, and no intonation issues. Stayed in tune. blah blah blah. 3 nights ago I decided to change them as they were starting to groove badly (the wound strings). For some reason I could not find my other pack of Tite-fits so I put more Slinkys back on. Went on fine, nice and warm, intonated fine, held tune, but still didn't feel quite right.

I found the pack of DR Tite-fits the next day, and put them on....and like I'd experienced before on other axes...horrible, horrible, tuning/intonation problems. Every string was WAYYY off being intonated. Nor would they HOLD tune for more tha 2 minutes. I tweaked and tweaked and 3 of the strings just would not intonate. Just like had happened on my Tokai, and my Explorer. I messed with the guitar for over 2 hours. Now the same exact strings (guage and type) previously had required no intonation tweaking, and also stayed rock solid in tune from the minute I put them on! WTF????

Off they came in my rage, and all I had laying around in nickel wrap was a set of D'addario 9-46 guage instead of my normal 10-46. I had a set of Pure Blues 10s laying around but I wasn't about to put MORE DR strings on this thing. The D'addarios went on without a hitch, and even with the difference in guage, the intonation was nearly perfect , they held tune, no issues whatsoever.

This is NOT the first time I've had this issue with DR strings...as I said, I had the same issues with them on my Explorer and my Tokai. On my USA Hamer Standard, my first Dean ML, and my Gibson Faded V, I had the winding and saddle breakage issues with the Pure Blues and the Tite-Fits. Then there are the rust plain strings (I'd say half of my 12 packs suffered from at least one rusty plain string) .

When you get a GOOD set, of DRs they are absolutely the most incredible strings for sound/feel/tuning I've played...but only about 1/3 of the sets of DR strings that I've bought have been these "incredible" strings.

I think DR should prolly stop making these by hand (as they so proudly claim on the packaging) and go with machines to get some shred of consistency. It's pretty sad that D'addario, GHS, EB....i.e. the "cheap" string companies can put out a far more consistent, and better built product for half the price.

GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr:yell:
 
Last edited:
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

stick with D'Addario and stop buying overpriced junk and you won't have these problems.

-Mike
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

stick with Ernie Ball's and stop buying overpriced junk and you won't have these problems.
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

:laugh2:

I've learned my lesson. My thought process was that now I have this really high end guitar and I'm just not gonna go cheap with it as regards to strings, accessories, blah blah. I even went out and bought one of those dunlop guitar care kits (and wow...what a difference the polish and cleaners make compared to the cheapo EB/washburn/Gibbo etc branded stuff I was using before).

The DRs when they are RIGHT are incredible strings...but I'ts like import axes, you gotta go through a dozen to find one really good one.

No thanks. I've tried pretty much all the big names in strings and various "alloys" from them all. It seems like the more they cost the worse they are (IME).

VERY aggravating when a guitar will NOT intonate or stay in tune for more than 30 seconds...
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

I've always had good luck with DRs. Maybe they keep most of the good ones down here in the South. :D
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

Dean Markley Forever! :D

As you know, I've had the same intonation/tuning and wear issues with DR's on 3 of my guitars. No more for me, thanks. I'll stick with Dean Markley Blue Steels.
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

D'addarios for 20 years here. 10-46s
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

I'm not really singing the praises of some other brand like Ernie Ball or D'Addario so much as I'm just dumbfounded at the inconsistency of these handmade EXPENSIVE strings...I have never even remotely experienced these kind of intonation/tuning/wear problems with ANY other brand.. or type (pure nickel, ss, nickel wrap)...Gibson..Dean Markley, Ernie Ball, D'addario, GHS, Fender, SIT, Maxima Golds, etc.. even the cheap@$$ MF branded strings.


:shrug:

Oh well.
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

I tried a few sets of the pure blues when they first came out and my experience was similar. I broke the E and B real quick and even a few of the wound strings. I now use D'Adarrio XL115's and I have no more string trouble!
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

I found EBs a little spaghettis like at the first try. I put on D'addarios and never, ever looked back. I just love their feel. I have to still try Rotosounds though.
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

Dean Markleys all the Way :headbang:
Blue Steels on electrics
Alchemies on Acooustic
SLR-2000s on bass(finding a good six-string set is tricky but those strings rock)
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

Would you just buy some Snake Oil Strings, and you'll never have this problem again. Seriously.

Want me to send you a set?
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

True that I've had to make tweaks to my intonation when installing a new set of DRs, but I've never had a set not intonate at all. Properly stretched and intonated, my guitars with DRs stay pretty solid. The only thing I've noticed with DRs that I didn't like was that they seem far more susceptible to temperature and humidity changes than your typical EB or D'Addarios. If you don't have control over the climate around the guitar then I could easily understand how DRs could be all over the place.

Sorry to hear of your problems, Jeff.

edit: I've NEVER had a DR string break, and I don't have issues of corrosion on them that are any worse than other string brands, and that's in a room with a consistent 50% humidity. I wonder how you keep getting stuck with so many batches of bad strings.
 
Last edited:
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

I'm not really singing the praises of some other brand like Ernie Ball or D'Addario so much as I'm just dumbfounded at the inconsistency of these handmade EXPENSIVE strings...I have never even remotely experienced these kind of intonation/tuning/wear problems with ANY other brand.. or type (pure nickel, ss, nickel wrap)...Gibson..Dean Markley, Ernie Ball, D'addario, GHS, Fender, SIT, Maxima Golds, etc.. even the cheap@$$ MF branded strings.


:shrug:

Oh well.

Don't know if they're still in biz but I used to buy some strings from stringthis.com, I think they were called "Memphis Blues" 10-46's that held up okay but usually ended up bustin' a G or E after several plays. D'addario for all my humbucker guitars and Fender Bullet's for my Strats.
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

I've never had good luck with DRs.

They've been out of the running for a long, long time.
 
Re: RANT: So help me god....I'm NEVARRR buying...

ive been using drs for years and other than the fact that the pure blues wear fast if you need a crown and polish i havent had much of a problem. im also a dr dealer so i dont pay all that much
 
Back
Top