Re: Using Your Amp's (Natural) Distortion
Gotta admit that I've never really owned a great amp... I get my dirt from amp modeling on my Zoom G5 going into the clean channel of a Fender Champion 100. When I was upgrading amps from my Crate earlier this year I considered going for a tube amp if for no other reason than that I've never had one and would kinda like to experience for myself what all the hype is about, but I can't crank up at home and we mic our amps into the PA in my band. I very rarely have it above about two-and-a-half for volume, so I decided to stay solid state clean and use models to get the tones I want because I doubt that I'd ever get to the amp's breakup volume.
All that being said, I love the sound(s) I've come up with for my basic setup doing it this way, so I just don't really feel the need to change. Many times I practice at home just using straight amp distortion, and many times I'll find myself wanting to figure out a good way to add it to my repertoire of sounds (it's not horrible, after all), but when I compare it to the distortions I'm getting from the Zoom I always realize that the amp's sound just isn't quite there.
Interestingly, the amp models I've used (both from Zoom and Line 6) always seem to sound much more natural than any pedal (or pedal model) that I've tried. My basic attitude toward OD pedals is that they're great for ADDITONAL gain, but rarely sound that great all by themselves.