Just to be clear, I'm not talking about "adding" another switch or knob. I'm talking about replacing a knob for a switch. 100% reversible, if you don't like it. The next step would be, don't worry about the 250k thing with split humbuckers. A split humbucker is not exactly the same as a single coil. It will probably be fine. The thing is, you can try both of those options and see where you stand, tonal-wise. Both, are 100% reversible, without scarring your pickguard.