What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

That90'sGuy

DyzaBoyzologist
This irritates me to no end. Fat necks these days are a rarity. What gives? Not everybody has small kids hands and it's bull that the market is full of these "fast", "sleek" and "comfort" necks everywhere (insert buzzwords of your choice).

If I want a Fender Telecaster with a rosewood fretboard and a fat neck I'm out of luck. If I want a MIA Fender with a fat neck I need to spring for a G.E. Smith sig. model (with the funky inlays) or a Nocaster. The American Standard series is the "comfort C" which is thin as **** and the '62 AVRI is even thinner. When I went shopping for a new Fender Strat a few years ago, I ended up having to buy a '56 RI Custom Shop Strat just to get a soft V profile that's a medium large profile. Other than the '54 and '56 Strats everything else (for the most part, anyhow) is much smaller. FENDER YOU HAVE EIGHTHUNDREDMILLION DIFFERENT VARIATIONS ON STRATS AND TELES AND YOU STILL MISS OUT ON SALES BY NOT OFFERING MORE MODELS WITH FAT NECKS. Isn't it sad out of all the models they have that if you want a rosewood fretboard, maple neck and a U carve or fat C carve it's impossible to get unless you specialty order stuff from a separate neck mfg. or pay 10x as much from the custom shop?

Take a look at Gibson. Most of the semi/hollowbodies out there are 60's slim taper profile. Les Paul Special DCs? 60's. Most SGs? 60's. They're on Explorers, Firebirds, etc. and the slim taper profile in general dominates the market. I had an Explorer that was amazing sounding, but that neck did me in, I had to sell it. That was just another reason to sell my SG Custom or my 2 CS LP Special DCs.

Other manufacturers are just as bad. G&L for instance. They insist on narrow f'n 1 5/8'' garbage necks with their "standard C" profiles. They do make other profiles, but good luck finding them as 99% of their production line is this mass produced small sh1te. Hagstrom? Narrow and small. Rickenbacker? Yup... polarizing neck profiles (in general). The Dean Chafin Del Sol I had was a more moderate sized neck. Hamer's generally run on the smaller side (at least the Specials I've owned). Same thing with the Don Grosh stuff I've owned. You just can't escape it. I can't possibly be the only one who feels this way, am I?

wheres-the-beef.jpg
 
Last edited:
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

Yeah, where the hell are the real men with big hands! :14:
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

As a Gibson player I prefer the fat 50s necks, but the slim 60s necks don't really bother me.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I don't have big hands, but even I was pleasantly surprised at how comfy I find the U-shaped neck on my Fender AV52. I thought I wouldn't like it simply because everything I've ever played had a standard C-shape profile, but I really really love that '52 neck. Now I find myself wishing my other American Standard and such C profile necks were thicker.

However, I DID try out a Fender Custom Shop Tele not too long ago that had the thickest neck I'd ever seen and I hated it from the second I picked it up. Same went for the Mike Dirnt signature P-Bass - it actually felt like a baseball bat and I couldn't play it.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

Yeah I noticed that about Fender's American Standards. I don't like playing those necks.

It's not just too thing, there aren't any shoulders and the fretboard angle is too steep.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I have little girl hands, so bigger necks are difficult for me. My favorite are the Music Man necks. But for a big fender neck try the Jeff Beck Strat.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I'm with Mincer. I dislike that I CAN'T get a LP Custom with a 60s neck. Of course, I couldn't afford it right this second, but I sent my 05 up the river just for that reason. It killed my hand. Count your blessings: at least you're not one of those guys who's addicted to some oddball shape like the ESP thin U or whatever.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I guess they don't sell too well?
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I play Ibanez for years, but I love fat V neck of my RI54 strat!
 
Last edited:
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I have small Hands but I have always loved fatter necks. Thats another reason why I have kept away from Shred guitars.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I hate thin necks too. I have a Charvel CX 291 whose neck is very thin and small and super easy to play, but I rarely play it cause it's...super easy to play! I like fat necks where I can fully wrap my palm around. The degree of thickness of a neck doesn't affect my playing more than the action of the strings is.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

Honestly, the thin neck is aimed more at the guys who use the classical hand positioning with the thumb in the back of the neck. Bigger profiles seem to appeal more to the guys that wrap the thumb around.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

Honestly, the thin neck is aimed more at the guys who use the classical hand positioning with the thumb in the back of the neck. Bigger profiles seem to appeal more to the guys that wrap the thumb around.

I agree. Only problem with a thinner neck, I find, is that bending strings is not as comfortable when grasping the neck. But, as a 'thumb behind the neck' player, I'm good with most neck profiles and the combination of fret size/radius/action has more of an influence.

Thin neck = easier to play is just a marketing gimmick to get people to fork out.

You guys who want fatties, you should play this guitar - it'll put all your vintage Fenders, Gibsons and JB Strats in the shade :).
Fryer_Brian_May_08.jpg
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

I recently had the opportunity to compare neck profiles on my Epi Lucille and my brother's Epi-by-Gibson Sheraton II. The Lucille has a deep, chunky D section. The Sheraton II neck would not be out of place on some Ibanez solid body guitars. The Lucille has more volume unamplified. It also has better tone.

Unfortunately, in the final analysis, both guitars are crud and should be sold on.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

-Classical guitars have thick necks, I don't think classical guitarists prefer thin necks.

-Unfortunately the 80's influenced a lot of people and the majority of guitarists prefer thin necks. I don't think the big companies whould insist on thin necks if they didn't sell.

-Since I played a McCarty back in 2000 I realized any guitar I would buy in the future should have a thick neck. I didn't found any I could afford so I started making my guitars with Warmoth parts. I have three now and I don't care for the blank headstocks or to take my money back as I don't plan to sell them. After my first Warmoth I stopped looking at bolt-on neck guitars, I can make anything I want according to my taste. No need to wait for any company to offer what I want.
 
Last edited:
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

-Unfortunately the 80's influenced a lot of people and the majority of guitarists prefers thin necks. I don't think the big companies whould insist on thin necks if they didn't sell.

But then, it that's mostly what's offered, that's what you're gonna get. Some probably assume that guitars only come with thin necks.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

-Classical guitars have thick necks, I don't think classical guitarists prefer thin necks.
+1
i play classical and a lot of solo fingerstyle, and i prefer thicker necks. It gives the thumb better positioning to act as a fulcrum for barring. All my axes have thick necks, with the exception of my strat which i think feels like a toy.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

See if you can find a Classic Player's 'Baja' Tele, that has a soft 'v' neck on it.
 
Re: What the heck is with guitar manufacturers and thin necks?

Honestly, the thin neck is aimed more at the guys who use the classical hand positioning with the thumb in the back of the neck. Bigger profiles seem to appeal more to the guys that wrap the thumb around.

It's the opposite with me. If I play in a more classical position on a thin neck, my hand cramps up. If I wrap my thumb around, I like a thinner neck because my hands are thick and my fingers are short.
 
Back
Top